About Me

My photo
Nazareth, Pa., United States
Showing posts with label Pennsylvania Superior Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pennsylvania Superior Court. Show all posts

Thursday, March 30, 2017

Give LV's Favorite Son, Emil Giordano, a Vote in Superior Court Race

The Express Times recently conducted an online poll on which boys' basketball player you'd want to see on the court in the 4th quarter. So naturally, I voted for my grandson and Jay Vaughan, who play together at Allentown Central Catholic. It was actually kind of funny because the top vote getters ended up being kids from schools that receive little attention instead of the powerhouses. The poll was just for fun.

Well, there's another poll going on right now that's just for fun. But this one is a PoliticsPA poll asking you which candidate will be the top vote getter in the GOP race for Superior Court. One of those candidates is the Lehigh Valley's very own Judge Emil Giordano. Because I'm a Democrat, I already voted for him 100 times. Our appellate courts need to include more people who are from outside Pittsburgh and Philly. I have nothing against those jurists, but would prefer to see different areas of the state better represented.

Saturday, October 31, 2015

Judge Giordano Needs Your Vote

I never have seen a larger crowd for a campaign kickoff than when Judge Emil Giordano announced in February that he was running for for the Pennsylvania Superior Court. He did so at the cavernous Northampton Memorial Community Center amid dozens of empty pizza boxes. Those boxes were empty because it seemed as though the entire Lehigh Valley had cascaded into Northampton, despite the single digit temperatures and mounds of snow everywhere. Some say there were about 600 people there, although it could easily have been 700. It was a bipartisan crowd, too. Democrats and Republicans. Lawyers and friends. Urbanistas and country folk. It was the Lehigh Valley. Northampton Mayor Thomas Reenock put it best when he called the gathering "our favorite son's debut."

Since that time, Judge Giordano's message has only grown stronger as he has criss crossed the state, in search of votes. But to win, he is going to need the same bi-partisan support he has had all along here in the Lehigh Valley. Democrats and Republicans are both going to have to come out and let their voices be heard. Send a message to Philadelphia, Pittsburgh and the land of midnight payraises.

The Lehigh Valley's favorite son also happens to be the son of two Italian immigrants who met while learning how to speak English in night school. They came here to raise a family and made pizzas. Lots of them. When Emil was old enough, he made pizzas, too. Lots of them. They got him through Bethlehem Catholic High School, Moravian College and Villanova Law School. Giordano learned about hard work. He learned to respect and admire his parents and grandparents, and to admire the many people who appear before him to become naturalized citizens. Most importantly, he learned how to listen.

"The time spent behind counters, waiting on people, served me very well," Giordano has said. In time, there was a law office adjacent to Pizza Village. And after 18 years of practicing law, he became a judge. And for the past 12 years, he has handled that role with humility and a genuine concern for everyone who comes before him,lawyers and non-lawyers alike.

At the same time, he has taught at Becahi and Moravian College. But where he has excelled is as a coach to young athletes, bringing out the best in them. I've seen him take groups of kids and win basketball championships despite claiming to know nothing about the sport. He knows how to motivate.

After 12 years as a judge, Emil Giordano is the same person he was before he put on a robe. Few other judges can make that claim.

Why is he running for the Pennsylvania Superior Court? That's the state's busiest court. It's an appellate court that reviews the decisions of common pleas judges in all 67 counties. Just to keep up, the 15 judges on that bench must each hand down one or two opinions daily.

Giordano already knows about hard work, He added that he would be a "common sense judge who follows the law." He also believes that the best person to evaluate the work of other judges is a person who once sat where they are sitting.

Why do people like him? Giordano, when he was still practicing law, once challenged Morganelli in a DA's race. That night, as the numbers came in, it was clear that Morganelli would be the victor. Instead of calling Morganelli to concede, Giordano actually walked into the Democratic stronghold and congratulated him in person.

That's class.

That's Giordano.

We could use some of that on our appellate courts.

If you want another Philadelphia judge, stay home. If you want someone who actually listens and does not consider himself better than you simply because he dons a black robe, you need to come out and vote. He needs Democrats and Republicans alike.

Thursday, October 29, 2015

More Local Support For Giordano Bandwagon

FROM EMIL GIORDANO CAMPAIGN – The Emil Giordano for Superior Court Committee is proud to announce the endorsement of Lehigh Valley officials,
including Republican State Representatives Mark Gillen and Barry Jozwiak, Democratic Lehigh County Executive Tom Mueller, Republican Berks County Commissioner Christian Leinbach, Democratic Berks County District Attorney John Adams and former Republican Allentown Mayor William Heydt.

“I am incredibly grateful for the tremendous amount of bipartisan support my campaign has received and I am confident that working together we will be successful on Election Day,” Judge Giordano said.

Judge Emil Giordano is running for a seat on the Pennsylvania Superior Court. Judge Giordano has been endorsed by the Republican Party of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania Fraternal Order of Police, Pennsylvania State Troopers Association, Pennsylvania Medical Society, National
Federation of Independent Businesses, Pennsylvanians for Effective Government, Le-Hampton Lodge 35 FOP, Allegheny County FOP, Queen City Lodge FOP, Scranton FOP, Pennsylvania Associated Builders and Contractors (ABC), ABC Eastern Pa. Chapter and has earned the "recommendation” of the Pennsylvania Bar Association, Firearms Owners Against Crime and LIFEPAC. Judge Giordano currently serves on
the Northampton Court of Common Pleas, a position he has held since 2003. Prior to being elected, Judge Giordano served as an assistant district attorney, assistant public defender, civil litigator and as lead counsel in his private law practice. Judge Giordano resides in Bethlehem with his wife Tina and his two sons, Joseph and Caden. For more information about Giordano’s campaign please visit EmilGiordanoforJudge.com.

Wednesday, October 28, 2015

Giordano Gets More Democratic Support

Judge Giordano and Steelworkers Prez Jerry Green
From the Emil Giordano Campaign: – The Emil Giordano for Superior Court Committee is proud to announce the endorsement of Lehigh Valley officials, including former Bethlehem Mayor John Callahan, former Northampton County Executive and County Council Member Gerald Seyfried and Jerry Green, President of the United States Steelworkers, Local 2599.

“I have known and worked with Emil Giordano for more than 25 years,” said John Callahan. “Emil Giordano is an experienced, qualified and honorable judge and I know he will be an excellent addition to the Pennsylvania Superior Court."

Judge Giordano added, “I am proud of the broad coalition of that has joined together in support of my campaign and I am confident that working together we will be successful on Election Day.”

Giordano's My father-in-law and mother-in-law were proud members of the Steelworkers Union.

Judge Emil Giordano is running for a seat on the Pennsylvania Superior Court. Judge Giordano has been endorsed by the Republican Party of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania Fraternal Order of Police, Pennsylvania State Troopers Association, Pennsylvania Medical Society, National Federation of Independent Businesses, Pennsylvanians for Effective Government, Le-Hampton Lodge 35 FOP, Allegheny County FOP, Queen City Lodge FOP, Scranton FOP, Pennsylvania Associated Builders and Contractors (ABC), ABC Eastern Pa. Chapter and has earned the “recommendation” of the Pennsylvania Bar Association, Firearms Owners Against Crime and LIFEPAC. Judge Giordano currently serves on the Northampton Court of Common Pleas, a position he has held since 2003. Prior to being elected, Judge Giordano served as an assistant district attorney, assistant public defender, civil litigator and as lead counsel in his private law practice. Judge Giordano resides in Bethlehem with his wife Tina and his two sons, Joseph and Caden. For more information about Giordano’s campaign please visit EmilGiordanoforJudge.com.

Wednesday, October 14, 2015

LV Dems Endorse Giordano for Superior Court

Judge Emil Giordano, flanked by his sister and brother
If you have insomnia and need help falling asleep, go to Northampton County Judge Emil Giordano's Facebook page. It's by no means boring, but you can't help but get tired after seeing all the places he has visited in his quest for one of the 15 seats on Pennsylvania's Superior Court. He's everywhere. By now, he must have met every registered voter at least seven times. In fact, looking at that page makes me realize that Pennsylvania really is a beautiful state.

Come November, I believe Lehigh Valley voters will be sending a third judge to a higher court.

Judge Giordano has qualities that every judge should possess. He is patient, courteous and willing to listen to both sides before he makes a ruling. Another quality is that he's an everyman. He carries no airs and you would never know he was a juge if you saw him off the bench.

It's rare to see prominent members of one party endorsea candidate in the other party, but it's happening for Judge Giordano. He's just picked up endorsements from former Democrat Superior Court Judge Robert Freedberg, former Democratic Court of Common Pleas Judge William Moran, Democratic Mayor of Easton Salvatore Panto Jr, Democratic Mayor of Whitehall Ed Hozza, Democratic Mayor of Northampton Tom Reenock, Mayor of the North Catasauqua Bill Molchany, Jr, and Democratic Bethlehem City Councilmen Eric Evans and Mike Recchiuti.

“I am honored to have the support of these strong and committed local elected officials and that they recognize that I am the best candidate to serve all Pennsylvanians on the Superior Court,” said Judge Giordano. “I have great respect for their work and I truly appreciate their support as I seek to serve all citizens of the Commonwealth as a judge on the Pennsylvania Superior Court.”

Judge Giordano has also been endorsed by the Republican Party of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania Fraternal Order of Police, Pennsylvania State Troopers Association, Pennsylvania Medical Society, National Federation of Independent Businesses, Pennsylvanians for Effective Government, Le-Hampton Lodge 35 FOP, Allegheny County FOP, Queen City Lodge FOP, Scranton FOP, Pennsylvania Associated Builders and Contractors (ABC), ABC Eastern Pa. Chapter and has earned the “recommendation” of the Pennsylvania Bar Association, Firearms Owners Against Crime and LIFEPAC.

Judge Giordano has been on the bench in Northampton County since since 2003. Prior to being elected, Judge Giordano served as an assistant district attorney, assistant public defender, civil litigator and as lead counsel in his private law practice. Judge Giordano resides in Bethlehem with his wife Tina and his two sons, Joseph and Caden.

He does not mention this, but let me tell you he is also one of the best youth sports coaches I've ever seen.

Judge Giordano's opponent in November is yet another Philadelphia judge. Nice lady, but I think we also have several of those.

Monday, October 05, 2015

Emil Giordano Poised to Win Seat in Superior Court

I'm used to seeing Emil Giordano on baseball fields and basketball courts during the hot days of summer, but he's MIA. He's instead been all over the state picking up the support he'll need to win a seat as one of the state's fifteen Superior Court judges. In fact, if you haven't done so, I'd recommend that you look at his Facebook page just to see all the great places and people in what really is a magnificent state.

This pic says it all. Who but Judge Giordano would not only let someone photobomb a campaign pic, but would also then load it onto his page?

A man with a sense of humor. A man who, despite working hard, is still willing to laugh at himself. That is Giordano. He is one Republican who will get my vote this election cycle. I suspect he will win big in Northampton County and throughout the state. He will lose Philly. That is where his opponent, Alice Dubow, is based. But he will win everywhere else and should win the race.

Wednesday, August 12, 2015

Giordano Wins State FOP Endorsement

A pizza shop - where Judge Giordano's journey began 
Northampton County Judge Emil Giordano, who is running for a seat on the Pennsylvania Superior Court, has received an important endorsement. The Pennsylvania Fraternal Order of Police will stand behind him in November. Judge Giordano can add this to three other law enforcement endorsements he has already received from the State Troopers' Association, the Bethlehem FOP and Le-hampton Lodge FOP.

The Pennsylvania Superior Court is one of two intermediate appellate courts between the county courts and the state supreme court. The Commonwealth handles disputes involving municipalities and government agencies. The 15-judge Superior Court has the rest, including the criminal caseload. Last year, that busy court decided 8.165 cases, including 5,063 criminal appeals.

Even with the help of senior judges, each judge decides more than one matter every day. They also meet at three different locations in Harrisburg, Philadelphia and Pittsburgh.

Annual salary is $175,923.

Judge Giordano's opponent is Philadelphia Judge Alice Beck Dubow, who has served as a common pleas judge since 2007. Giordano has been a judge since 2001. But that's not what sets him apart. What does is that he has somehow managed to remain the same person he was when he got elected. Despite the robe, he refuses to assume airs.

Tuesday, July 14, 2015

Pa Business Council Endorses Giordano For Superior Court

Northampton County Judge Emil Giordano, who has been visiting county after county across the state in his quest for a seat on the Pennsylvania Superior Court, has received the important endorsement of Pennsylvania Business Council.

Unlike many endorsements, this one was unusually informative. David W. Patti, who is President and CEO of the PBC, points out that the 15 judges of the Superior Court only rarely sit together. Most cases are instead decided by three-judge panels. "An overall pro-business majority on a court is no guarantor of a pro-business majority among panelists," reasoned Patti. "That’s why it’s crucial we elect a well-qualified, experienced jurist like Emil Giordano to the Superior Court.”

Judge Giordano has served on the Northampton County Court of Common Pleas since 2003 and his background includes time as an ADA, a public defender and in private practice where he worked on civil law cases. It also includes a lot of selfless service to the community as a baseball and basketball coach, where he has helped mold many fine young men, including my grandson. He also knows a lot about the plight of small business owners because he worked in his father's pizza business while attending school.

He denies, however, that he is installing a pizza oven in his courtroom.

Patti said the Pa Business Council is confident that Giordano will always balance the rights and needs of plaintiffs and defendants fairly. “Judge Giordano’s parents emigrated from Italy and settled in the Lehigh Valley looking for the American Dream. He knows what hard work and tenacity it takes to achieve success. Judge Giordano will always be protective of the rights of Pennsylvania’s working families.”

The Pa Business Council decides who to support based on whether the candidate is friendly to the business community, regardless of party. This is the latest in a growing list of endorsements that include the Pa. State Troopers Ass'n, the Bethlehem FOP and the Le-Hampton FOP.

Wednesday, May 06, 2015

Bethlehem's FOP Endorses Judge Giordano For Super Court

Judge Giordano with a new American citizen
Last week, I told you that the Pennsylvania State Troopers' Association has endorsed Northampton County jurist Emil Giordano for a seat on Pennsylvania's Superior Court. You can now add Bethlehem's FOP, which represents police officers who serve Bethlehem. The law enforcement community believes Judge Giordano, who on the Superior Court will weigh in on many criminal cases, will consider the need for public safety and victims' rights when deciding on the merit of criminal appeals.

Giordano, who lives in Hanover Township with his wife and two sons, is also one of the best youth coaches in the Lehigh Valley.

Tuesday, April 21, 2015

Giordano Gets ABC Endorsement

Superior Court candidate Emil Giordano, who currently sits on the Northampton County Court of Common Pleas, has earned the endorsement of the Associated Builders and Contractors (ABC) Eastern Pa. Chapter.

“Giordano has demonstrated his strong commitment to community and free enterprise values. It is evident that he understands the construction industry and the merit philosophy that ABC represents,” said Mary Tebeau, President and CEO of the ABC Eastern Pa. Chapter.

Judge Giordano, first elected in 2003, has already received the endorsement of the Republican Party of Pennsylvania. he has also been recommended by the Pennsylvania Bar Association.

Judge Giordano has also served as an assistant district attorney, assistant public defender, civil litigator and as lead counsel in his private law practice. He resides in Bethlehem with his wife, Tina, and his two sons, Joseph and Caden.

If you were to ask him, he'd tell you his proudest accomplishment is his two sons, who are great kids. For years, son Joseph and niece Victoria Tesone collected used baseball and softball equipment to distribute to younger kids, making it possible for them to play.

His sons also have more common sense. Caden, for example, wants to be a doctor.

ABC Eastern Pennsylvania Chapter represents more than 14,000 merit construction employees who work for nearly 450 member companies. ABC was founded on the belief that construction projects should be awarded on merit to the most qualified and lowest responsible bidder. Nationally Associated Builders and Contractors is comprised of 70 chapters representing nearly 21,000 merit shop construction and construction-related firms with nearly two million employees.

Thursday, April 09, 2015

Judge Giordano Has a Party

Judge Giordano and his former law clerks
Northampton County Judge Emil Giordano, who has been criss-crossing the state in his quest for a seat on the Superior Court, had a chance to relax night with friends at the Hotel Bethlehem.It might have been a fundraiser, but Judge Giordano was only asking for ten. Not $10,000 or even $10. Ten votes.

So this Spring, I will have to vote for Judge Giordano ten times.As a Democrat, I'm used to that sort of thing.

I told people Judge Giordano had invited me to this event, and they bought it. I was able to wolf down three helpings of shrimp before security got wise and tossed me.

I love these judge events because they attract people from both parties, and they generally are very positive.

Lehigh County DA Jim Martin was there. Judge Giordano credited him as "running the best race possible - unopposed." NorCo Judge Paula Roscioli was there, and I wanted to get her picture just as my camera died. By the time I got new batteries in, she had vanished. Some say she jumped out a window when she saw me coming.

All three of the Northampton County judge candidates - Abe Kassis, Sam Murray and Vic Scomilio - were present. We are very lucky because any one of them would be excellent on the bench.

Jeff Kocsis (left) and Shawn Martell (right)
Bethlehem City Council candidates Shawn Martell and Jeff Kocsis got some special treatment. Like Judge Giordano and yours truly, they are graduates of both Becahi and Moravian.

City Council member Eric Evans was unable to make it, but his beautiful wife was there, and he should send her to all his functions. Eric had the best of all possible excuses for his absence. Baseball. For that reason alone, he deserves re-election. When his wife mentioned he was at baseball practice, Judge Giordano bowed his head, and I genuflected.

Robert Freedburg, former President Judge of Northampton County, has agreed to sign on as counsel to Judge Giordano's campaign committee. Former Judge Bill Moran has also endorsed Judge Giordno's campaign.  

The most touching part of the night was when Judge Giordano called on his former law clerks to come up with him. He had taught several of them at Moravian.

What's really appealing about Judge Giordano is that he is the same person he was when he was first elected. He has assumed no airs. At basketball and baseball games, people know him as Emil, not judge. I was talking to a fairly partisan democrat who sat on the jury twice for Judge Giordano. He could not get over how nice and decent a person he is. And he is, on and off the bench.

But what most don't know is that he is an excellent coach.  He brings out the best in young kids learning baseball or basketball. Unlike many of those involved in organized youth sports, he teaches the kids to have fun. The end result has been several championships.

Tuesday, February 10, 2015

Judge Wecht Wants to "Clean Up" Judiciary

David Wecht, a Democrat who currently is serving on the Superior Court, is one of 15,678 candidates seeking one of three seats on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. That court's reputation has been tarnished by two justices - one Democrat and one Republican - who were forced to resign after being embroiled in scandals. This occurred while we were still reeling from the Kids for Cash scandal in Lackawanna County.

Unfortunately, this cancer has spread to other branches of government, including state legislators, the Attorney General and former State treasurer.

We need judges whose integrity is beyond reproach. People like Sam Murray, to whom due process actually mean something. People like Emil Giordano, one of very few judges who is as approachable and down-to-earth today as he was when he was first elected. And it seems that Superior Court Judge David Wecht has the right idea.

According to PoliticsPa, he has a five-point plan to restore public perception of the court's integrity.
  • Absolute ban on all gifts to judges
  • Tightened Anti-Nepotism Policy; Sunset Employment of Judges’ Relative
  • Require judges to rule on the record in writing on all motions for recusal
  • Mandated ethics courses for all judicial candidates
  • Television broadcast of court proceedings

Saturday, January 31, 2015

GOP State Committee Endorses Giordano For Superior Court

The Republican State Committee has endorsed Northampton County's very own Emil Giordano for a seat on the state Superior Court.  So far as I know, no one will challenge that choice at the polls, and Judge Giordano is virtually assured the Republican nomination. Lehigh County Judge Doug Reichley, a former state representative, considered making a run of it, but withdrew.

Friday, January 23, 2015

Two LV Judges Ponder State Superior Court Races

Two Lehigh Valley jurists are currently pondering a run at the State Superior Court. They are Northampton County Judge Emil Giordano, who is serving his second ten-year term; and Lehigh County Judge Doug Reichley, first elected in 2011. Both are Republicans.

Between the two of them, Judge Giordano is by far the more experienced on the bench, while Reichley's ten terms as a State Rep. might give him better connections with State Committee members.

I know and like them both. But to me, this is a no-brainer. Judge Giordano, both of whose parents came here from Italy with little more than the shirts on their backs, is very much unlike your typical judge. Most of them tend to think they've become gods, but Judge Giordano has never assumed any of the airs you sometimes see in others. He has the courage to say he does not know the answer to everything. At the same time, as is the tradition in Northampton County, he shows great respect to all people who come before him, This is a trait he no doubt learned from his parents.

He shows this same respect out of the courtroom as well. His has been a life of service. He particularly excels at coaching. One of his players was my grandson, who adores him.

I have no desire to slam Reichley, whom I consider a man of conviction and courage. Either would be excellent. But I prefer the judge with a heart.

We already have Judge Jack Panella sitting on the Superior Court, but I'd like Lehigh Valley judges occupy all fifteen seats.

Friday, November 01, 2013

Judge Jack Panella Needs Your Vote

Believe it or not, many years ago, a Northampton County judge ruled that I was a "credible" witness. Though his holding was only limited to the circumstances in a boundary dispute in which I was a title searching expert, but it made me feel very special. It's been downhill ever since. I hope this doesn't cost him the election, but that judge was none other than Jack Panella. He's seeking retention to the Superior Court, and i hope you can vote Yes for him next week. Several times.

Judge Panella is a rock star at the Northampton County Courthouse. When he drops by, everyone flocks to him, from President Judge to clerk. Though he's an appellate jurist, you'd never know it once the robe is off.

Lawyers tend to have a bad reputation because of assholes like me, who have engaged in unethical conduct and have had our tickets pulled. But there's an occasional crop of lawyers who represent the very best in that profession. Panella was in that group. After graduating, they teamed up and drove to Philly daily one summer in the same shitty car to study for the bar, scarfing hot dogs for lunch if they had money. This distinguished cadre of young men included John Morganelli (Northampton County DA), Jay Leeson (Bethlehem City Council), Phil Hof and Jack Panella (Superior Court Judge). They were all admitted to Northampton County's Bar together.

In this elite group of barristers, Panella excelled. He served as an assistant county solicitor, and was soon named County Solicitor, back when Gene Hartzell ran a very tight and happy ship in Northampton County. Panella was the youngest person ever named as the county's top legal eagle. He then became the second youngest person to serve as a Northampton County judge, being appointed to the bench in 1991.

During his days as a common pleas judge, Panella fell in love with running. "It saved my life," he tells me. If you run 5 ks anywhere in this state, you might be running with him. I remember driving with him and a collection of other lawyers like Mike Vedomsky, Danny Cohen and Phil Hof to run a ten mile race in Brooklyn one Sunday. Panella may have been a judge, but that day he was a runner.

Although he could stay on the bench forever in Northampton County, Panella is a scholar. So he decided to buck the odds and run for Superior Court. Amazingly, he won, and in 2004, he became an appellate judge.

Of fifteen superior court jurists, only Judge Jack Panella (Lehigh Valley) is from the eastern part of the state.

Being a superior court judge is a great honor, but it's also a lot of work. The judges literally ride the circuit. They spend one week each month in Pittsburgh, Harrisburg or Philly, sitting in three-judge panels to listen as lawyers argue that some lower court committed a legal error.

That's why the superior court is often called the court of second guess. It's where most appeals from a trial court are heard. The vast majority of the appeals filed last year, were from criminal convictions. Because the supremes are so reluctant to hear appeals, the superior court is usually the last bastion of hope for those seeking justice.

Panella told me he must write at least one opinion every day just to keep up with the workload. To give you an idea of what's involved, you must first sit down and read transcripts, a lower court opinion and the briefs filed by all sides to a dispute. Then you have to research the law yourself. It's almost as hard as blogging!

Panella has one piece of advice for lawyers arguing in the superior court - don't try to predict the outcome. "I'm almost always wrong when I try to guess how judges are going to decide something."

Panella would go on to run and lose in a Supreme Court race against Joan Orie Melvin, who was recently convicted of using state resources in support of her campaign. He was cheated out of the seat, but has no bitterness.

In addition to his work on the bench, Judge Panella has written several bench books to help trial judges.  He also schedules periodic lectures, and earleier this year, sponsored a fascinating lecture about the only time the United States Supreme Court exercised original jurisdiction and conducted a criminal trial for contempt of court. It did so in a case involving a Sheriff who turned his head the other way when an innocent black man was lynched and hung.

A vote to retain Judge Panella is not a vote for him. It is a vote for us all.

Wednesday, September 04, 2013

Superior Court Finds Criminal Harassment in Facebook Post

Thanks to a recent Superior Court ruling, West Easton troublemaker Tricia Mezzacappa and her Blog Mentor may soon find themselves charged with criminal harassment. In an August 3 ruling a three-judge panel affirmed a conviction based on a Defendant's Facebook posting that "[Victim] has herpes. Ew, that's gross. She should stop spreading her legs like her mother."  The victim in this case was a 15 year-old girl getting ready for her first day of school.

The comment was reported to police, who filed the charges. The Defendant admitted her actions were wrong, but not criminal. Judge Christine L. Donohue disagreed:

"[I]n light of the totality of the evidence, her misuse of the internet and social media was criminal. The evidence of record establishes that Cox posted a statement in dicating that the Victim suffered from a sexually transmitted disease on an online forum, and that this statement was viewed by multiple people. We conclude this is sufficient to support a finding that Cox communicated lewd sentiments about Victim to other people, and an inference that in so doing it was her intent to harass, annoy or alarm Victim."

Tricia Mezzacappa has repeatedly referred to Bethlehem Mayoral hopeful Jim Gregory's ex girlfriend and her mother with similarly disparaging language on Mezzacappa's blog and on the AM airwaves. I will not repeat the language used here. Her Blog Mentor has repeatedly made disgusting, and false, implications about a recently ordained Maronite Catholic priest on his blog.

Northampton County District Attorney John Morganelli is a free speech purist, but has authorized criminal prosecutions against Mezzacappa for her venomous attacks against private people, those I call civilians. For example, he approved a complaint after repeatedly bashed and denounced a West Easton Borough Clerk. That poor lady ultimately resigned rather than face Mezzacappa rages. But Mezzacappa was convicted, and a judge told her he does not want to see her before him again.

Gregory's ex girlfriend and her mother are civilians, too. They've already been victimized by a woman beater. Now his wannabe girlfriend is trying to harass her to the point where she'll give up, and stop pursuing contempt charges.

In the meantime, Mezzacappa seeks a continuance of a criminal case pending against her "for medical reasons," but has the time on the day of her scheduled summary trial to be the guest host on Gregory's now mothballed radio show. She obviously has no respect for anyone, not even the Court.

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Superior Court Special Session at NCC to Honor Veterans

Boys & Girls Club Dean Young (L) and Judge Jack Panella (R) 
Earlier this moth, I attended a fascinating lecture at Lafayette College concerning the one and only time the United States Supreme Court has ever conducted a criminal trial. It happened in 1906, when a Chattanooga Sheriff thumbed his nose at a Supreme Court Order. Justice John Marshall Harlan intervened in the scheduled hanging of a black man who was convicted in state court of raping a white woman on evidence that was woefully inadequate. The Sheriff, a former Confederate soldier, would rather hand him over to the mob than a federal judge. And that's what happened.

Since there was no federal homicide statute at the time, the best feds could do was charge the Sheriff with contempt. He spent 90 days in federal prison for his involvement in the murder of a black man, and returned home to a hero's welcome in Chattanooga.

It might sound like a meaningless case to you, especially since the Sheriff only got 90 days, which he could do standing on his head. But it might be among the High Court's more significant rulings.

It was the first time a black lawyer was permitted to argue a case before the Supreme Court. It was the first time that the Supremes ruled that they have jurisdiction over claims that federal constitutional rights have been violated in state court proceedings.

This terrific lecture was sponsored by Superior Court Judge Jack Panella and Northampton County Judge Leonard Zito.

After bringing the law to Lafayette, Judge Panella is bringing it to Northampton Community College. Literally. This is no lecture, but an actual session of the Pennsylvania Superior Court, both today and tomorrow.

The state superior court is a 15-judge appellate court that hears appeals from county decisions. Although the Supreme Curt occasionally will review their decisions, that is rare So their decision is the final word in most cases.

It's an extremely busy bench that still rides the circuit. Judges bounce from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh to Harrisburg, and each jurist averages at least one opinion a day. But there are times when President Judge Cory Stevens (a coal cracker) will allow cases to be heard at colleges and county courthouses. And he's given Judge Panella permission to conduct a session, both today and tomorrow, at Northampton Community College's Lipkin Theatre.

Both court sessions will begin at 9 a.m. each day during which a panel of Superior Court judges will hear oral arguments on appeals from local civil, criminal and domestic trial court cases. Tuesday’s session will be preceded by a first-of-its-kind opening ceremony to honor veterans that will include a presentation of the colors and pledge of allegiance. It is open to the public.

Judge Jack A. Panella will be the presiding judge on a panel that will include Judge Cheryl Lynn Allen and Senior Judge William H. Platt. Judge Panella served on the Northampton County Common Pleas Court prior to being elected to Superior Court. Judge Platt served on the Lehigh County Common Pleas Court, where he used to scare the hell out of me. Judge Allen hails from Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, and won despite all odds.

“Honoring veterans is meant to acknowledge that our government — and especially our armed services — have fought to maintain the high standards of judicial freedom and independence that our Constitution requires,” Judge Panella explained.

I was invited, but unfortunately, I'll be in the court of first guess tomorrow in Northampton County.

Should I avoid the gallows, I'll drop in on Wednesday and try to give you all a first hand report.