On June 23, 2025, repeated calls to 911 occurred when Octavia Robinson, an agency nurse who was suffering some sort of mental health breakdown, decided to perform an exorcism on a resident (E.B.) by assaulting her. In addition to sticking fingers down E.B.'s throat and stuffing clothes and towels into E.B's mouth, Robinson was seen pounding E.B.'s back and chest with her fist, screaming that there was a demon inside E.B. This assault continued for 30 minutes before police responded. She was seriously injured and died shortly after the assault though her death was unrelated to the assault.
In the 14 months that have passed since this incident, the county has yet to establish an official protocol with police concerning 911 calls and what is or is not an emergency. My understanding is that when receiving a 911 call, the dispatcher will first contact Gracedale to determine whether there is a real emergency. But no formal policy has been established, even after residents made multiple calls to 911 about a mentally ill nurse who was allegedly assaulting a resident. On June 23, three calls had to be made before a nursing supervisor got off her ass to check out the complaint. Then it was she who placed the fourth call.
It is this incident, and an obvious breakdown in communications between Gracedale and Upper Nazareth police, that led District Attorney Steve Baratta to commence a Grand Jury investigation. You would think that something that sparked a grand jury investigation might induce Gracedale and county administrators to establish a formal policy. According to Upper Nazareth Tp Police Chief William Cope, he has reached out several times and has written to the county but has been ignored.
At Wednesday's Gracedale Oversight Committee hearing, Continuum of Care Director Tom Carson told Council member Jason Boulette that he asked for a meeting but has received no response.
But he only asked for a meeting this week. ... 14 months after an assault in which a resident could easily have been killed.
Boulette told Carson that Chief Cope requested a meeting in June and after the Grand Jury report, releases a statement saying that he had followed up on that letter and had requested a meeting.
"I've been in contact with him," said Boulette. "I know he's been reaching out and trying to get a meeting."
I don't know about you, but I am simply astonished that Gracedale has made no effort to establish a formal 911 protocol. Administrator Michelle Morton should have been on top of this as soon as it became clear that three 911 calls were made before a nursing supervisor decided to do her job.
This is clear mismanagement, and it has continued until now.
Michelle Morton should be fired. End of story. In the business world she would be long gone.
ReplyDeleteAND they want to give michelle ,Christine ,DON and 2 ADON a step up in pay!!! And Tara is dragging her feet to open union contract when it could be done any time!!!!Please help stop this SOMEONE!!!!!!!
DeleteBi g Government is our problem the less government involvement the better we will be,
ReplyDeleteDo to the seriousness and lack of administration response, someone should be held accountable and fired.
ReplyDelete“My understanding is that when receiving a 911 call, the dispatcher will first contact Gracedale to determine whether there is a real emergency.”
ReplyDeleteThis is negligence and stupidity disguised as policy.
If a complaint comes from a private nursing home, or even a private single-family residence, does a 911 dispatcher call back to confirm that it’s a legitimate call? I would hope not, even if there is a history of false alarms coming from that private home or residence.
Minutes (and seconds) matter in a real emergency, and for county dispatchers to waste ANY time before sending police, fire or ambulance services IMMEDIATELY to ANY call seems almost criminally negligent and exposes the county (and its taxpayers) to tremendous liability (whether the call is about Gracedale or not).
In addition, when there is policy for county-paid dispatchers to treat a county-owned facility differently than any other caller, then the “policy” actually becomes an institutionalized coverup.
This isn’t difficult. While there can be fines or penalties for repeated false calls, ALL 911 calls need to be dispatched immediately and there should be no special treatment for any caller or location.
A competent executive would have already made it clear that ALL calls deserve the same treatment, no matter where they come from. The 911 system is there to take calls and dispatch the proper service (police, fire, ambulance) to the call. It is then the responsibility of the emergency crews to show up and deal with the call.
Police have no obligation to respond to 911 calls as a matter of law. They must be answered and dispatched, but there is no affirmative obligation imposed on police to respond to all calls. In the case of Gracedale, a resident actually placed 275 calls to 911 over a 18-month period. https://lehighvalleyramblings.blogspot.com/2026/03/the-gracedale-resident-who-called-wolf.html
DeleteThis prevents police from responding to real emergencies or in discounting a 911 call about an assault at Gracedale that nursing supervisors fail to verify.
The fact that no protocol has been established with UNT police in the 14 months after this exorcist nurse, despite police reaching out, is pure mismanagement.
Police might not have an obligation to respond, but that is not the issue here. The issue is the obligation of the county 911 dispatchers.
DeleteTheir job is to give that call to the appropriate police, fire, or ambulance service. Period.
If they are doing anything other than that, they are exposing the county to a lawsuit.
BTW, if the police decide not to answer a call, then that’s on them. Then they are the ones exposing themselves to a lawsuit and possible firing of the personnel making the decision not to respond.
Imagine if the nurse involved in the Gracedale incident HAD murdered the resident. They’d be sued into oblivion, and public outcry would rightfully force the chief and politicians involved out of their jobs.
I understand that responding to false calls can prevent emergency services from responding to legitimate calls. At the same time, would those in charge be able to prove that every officer was otherwise engaged on a call and not sitting in the station or in the vehicles in a parking lot? They do all have radios so that they can be contacted if additional information comes to light about the veracity of the call.
As I noted, those placing false calls can rightfully face fines, penalties or imprisonment. But the obligation of county dispatchers to refer the call to the proper emergency service is absolute, and they should not have a choice in the matter.
Does the county 911 center have a policy or arrangements with any private facility, business or residence where they won’t dispatch emergency services without additional confirmation? If so, who and where are they?
If not, why don’t Gracedale residents deserve the same level of service that the rest of us get?
To the disgruntled person… the police are made aware of all 911 calls from Gracedale. Typically, before anyone contacts Gracedale. However, while police are responding they can get a detailed update on the legitimacy of the 911 call placed. They (police) can then decide their response mode or if they respond at all. To the best of my knowledge calls aren’t held till clarified, so no theres no negligence on the communication centers part.
DeleteA real opportunity missed here by Baratta. The Upper Nazareth police department does not have the discretion to fail to respond to 911 calls. Yet, that night, the Upper Nazareth police failed to respond to two 911 calls. How did they know they were talking to a Supervisor and not a perpetrator ?
ReplyDeletePolice have no obligation to respond to a 911 call. A 911 call must be answered and referred as a matter of law, but police do have discretion to ignore the referral. Because of the large number of residents who cry wolf at Gracedale, it is absolutely necessary for nursing staff to establish a policy that ensures these calls are real emergencies. The failure to do so for 14 months after the exorcist is complete mismanagement
DeleteNo, it’s up to Gracedale to properly watch over their patients to prevent false calls from being made.
DeleteAgain, tell me one other private nursing home, business, or single family home that has an arrangement with the county 911 dispatchers or any emergency service (police, fire, ambulance) in the county to ignore calls until further confirmation is received.
My guess is that there isn’t one, because that would delay a response in the event of a real call (like it did with the exorcist).
Minutes lost are lives lost. Gracedale residents deserve the same emergency coverage the rest of the county does. If a resident is continuously making false reports, the burden is on Gracedale to come up with a way to stop that.
Reaching side agreements that lengthen response times is not a solution. I can’t imagine any competent fire, police or EMS chief that would agree to such an arrangement.
Police, ambulance and fire services should have to roll the minute a call is made. If additional information comes to light after that, they can be recalled by the responding service and (if the call is legitimate) THEY can be the ones who explain why they didn’t continue their response.
If there is what ends up being a massive fire at Gracedale and an immediate response to any call isn’t the “protocol”, are you going to explain to the families of dozens of residents that their loved ones died because someone was worried about the initial call being a false alarm?
I didn’t think so.
I suspect the real issue here is that the count is trying to shift the responsibility of not responding to calls to the police, ambulance and fire services, who need to be responding immediately to every call.
DeleteThe reality is that Gracedale is so poorly supervised that if a legitimate call (or calls in the case of the exorcist) come in it would take too long (or at least longer than the emergency service response) for anyone with authority at Gracedale to confirm it.
Setting up side agreements with first responders to not immediately respond is not the answer. It’s a recipe for disaster.
Let me ask the obvious question:
If a Gracedale resident (or residents) is making numerous false calls, why isn’t Gracedale removing or modifying their phone privileges? Isn’t Gracedale being fined like private homes for numerous false calls? If not, why aren’t they?
Nobody is above the law or should receive special treatment, right?
I wouldn't send my worst enemy to gracedale.
ReplyDelete"This is clear mismanagement, and it has continued until now."
ReplyDeleteYou have no idea about the "until now" part. With the Gracedale performance history you've endlessly documented, a more accurate report would state, "until next time." This took 14 months because nobody cares and they wish you'd just go away with all your noticing. Please don't. Please keep reporting on the fraud that is the county's mismanagement that's gotten worse under the Zrinski cabal.
Why hasn’t the assistant nursing home administrator ever been mentioned? Does Gracedale have 1? Is she/ he left out of the “loop” because she’s/he’s actually qualified and the powers that be feel inadequate? The DON & ADONS are terrible and have no leadership or managerial skills.
ReplyDeleteI have just looked her up and she is highly educated in several fields, including nursing. She is very experienced and seems far more qualified than either Carson or Morton. I have no idea why no one tapped her as Continuum of Care Director or Administrator.
DeleteNo matter what the obligation to the residents is the highest priority of the DON. It is their job to write and implement plan of corrections to deficiencies or ANY incident that occurs so that it hopefully will not occur in the future. Thats how you fix issues. No matter the qualifications if he/she is not doing that ...its also on the DON.
DeleteBecause she’s smarter than them.
DeleteThis County is in crisis- with an exception of a few, we are being led by incompetent people who are more concerned about their political future, than fixing problems that have festered for years.
ReplyDeleteTara is trying to fix the wrongs. Hence the tax increase. Minus Brown’s increase roughly 12 years ago which was then cut out by Lamont 5-6 years ago there hasnt been a tax increase in roughly 16-18 years! That is crazy, yes im a county taxpayer. Also know that capital projects have been cut annually to prevent tax increases year after year. Many employees are making roughly $15 an hour some with 15+ years of service. Sure these employees can find work elsewhere but whats the cost for that healthcare to cover the employee snd their children?
DeleteThank you for your fearless reporting. This administration has no clue what they're doing! Maybe Zrinski will get off social media & out of her jeans, and try to solve problems, rather than show up for photo ops.
ReplyDeleteZrinski doesn't go to her office until 11 am every day. She doesn’t respect the position. If Zrinski did, she would be more serious at the podium when speaking to the taxpayers.
ReplyDeleteI hope Tara reads this comment. It clearly comes from a County employee. What an ingrate. You now have 19 paid holidays total because of Tara. She is raising taxes and pouring gasoline like Jermaine Greene all over her political career for YOU !
DeleteShe's incompetent and it shows every time she opens her mouth.
DeleteBernie, I thinks it’s time for a bike ride to Easton in morning to see what Tara’s work habits are lol.
DeleteThanks for the suggestion but I usually avoid riding in the early morning unless it’s really hot. Also, a county exec is not like a clerk in the civil division. She has commitments outside of the courthouse that are in the best interests of the county. It’s a bit unfair to tag her simply bc she works hours and places that differ from you. I’ve never heard anyone accuse her of laziness, and if you are doing that, you are frankly full of shit.
DeleteNah I was being sarcastic lol. However, I get it that that the meet and greet stuff is part of the gig, right now we have a crisis. She needs to be meeting with her executive staff, formulating a course of action, and helping them execute it.
DeleteAll I know is the buck stops with the person that wears the crown. Tara Zrinski.
ReplyDeleteThis is absolute nonsense. I will bet that the meeting conflict is on County’s side. Mr. Carson should just man up and meet with Chief Cope and develop a mutual agreement AND THEN present it to his boss as DONE. Otherwise the Committee will do a Mexican Hat dance until people just leave.
ReplyDeleteThe nursing supervisor likely works for a vendor, instead of the County. Taking the meeting was likely a good step. Question is if it will solve the problem.
ReplyDeleteBernie hates when I say negative things about Tara but she’s in over her head and with 2 Gs and a D we could lose Gracedale
ReplyDeleteShe is an elected official and I am fairly lenient when it comes to them, but much of what you say is horseshit. I hate to read people constantly write the same vitriol over and over without addressing the substance of a post. Like this matter. You could have written that Tara Zrinski has had nine months to establish a protocol and that her failure to do so is management on her part as well as that of Gracedale's administrator. You instead just bray that she's "incompetent," "in over her head," etc. When you make these allegations, explain why you make them.
Delete“If it walks like a duck, sounds like a duck…”
DeleteTZ, Kraft, Keegan, and Warren have ALL served terms long enough to know the past problems that have NOT been addressed, yet they continue to fail at searching for answers by
Deletenot researching, connecting to, and speaking with Holland, Premier Diem Freeman, and local successful homes. They keep stating they will fix things, but they seem paralyzed and unable to act.
Council people DO get paid a salary for DOING that which is needed for the county. Time to hold them accountable for what they were elected to do and what they receive money for, no matter how small.
ReplyDeleteDidn’t you write an article in the past about a resident calling 911 constantly from Gracedale? I believe that was before the incident. Could that have been part of the problem along with all the other nonsense. Did anything happen to the resident making those phone calls?
ReplyDeleteYes, I did write a story about this individual and she was charged criminally with false reports
Delete