Thursday, October 18, 2012

School Principals, Psychtherapist, Testify Aganst Atiyeh Rehab

(From left to right: Solicitor Erich Schock and ZHB members Gus Loupos, Bill Fitzpatrick, Linda Shay Gardner and Michael Santanasto. James Schantz is blocked, but he's there.)

Two school principals and a psychotherapist spoke against Abe Atiyeh's quest for a residential drug and alcohol rehab center during a 4 1/2 hour hearing before Bethlehem's five-member Zoning Hearing Board (ZHB) on October 16. About thirty-five people attended this second night of testimony concerning this proposed facility, which would be located at 2110 Center Street. That's just 380' from Bethlehem High School, and right next door to Vitalistic Therapeutic Charter School.

At an earlier hearing in September, Atiyeh's engineer, David Harte, outlined plans for a 28-bed facility, 2 1/2-story treatment center for drug and alcohol addiction, to be staffed by a maximum of 16 people at any one time.

Ron Deiaco, principal and acting CEO of Vitalistic Therapeutic Charter School, told zoners he had concerns about the possibility of inappropriate contacts between treatment center residents and the 100 elementary school children under his care. "As a principal, my first concern is the safety of my children," he testified, noting that kids playing outside during recess could come into contact with residents taking smoke breaks outside.

Just that day, Deiaco testified, somebody wondered into the school, looking for the yet-to-be-built rehab center.

When ZHB member Bill Fitzpatrick asked whether a fence would address those concerns, Deiaco acknowledged that "it would certainly be a start." He also admitted, in response to cross-examination by Atiyeh Attorney Mark Malkames, that he conducted no Megan's law search before moving into his new school in September.

According to the Megan's Law Website, two registered sex offenders live within a mile of his charter school.

Principal John Petruzzelli
Bethlehem Catholic Principal John Petruzzelli stated that, because of the "tremendous stigma" associated with narcotics addiction, his 745-student school would see its enrollment decline. It would also negatively affect its land value. "Please do not threaten our ability to interest parents and attract students," he pleaded. "Please don't threaten our viability."

Petruzzelli conceded, under questioning by Attorney Malkames, that he had no evidence demonstrating that a treatment center would lead to increased crime or violence in the neighborhood.

But William Henry, a psychotherapist who can walk from his home to the proposed center in thirty seconds, claimed that there is a connection. Between 50-75% of people suffering from drug or alcohol addiction also suffer from an underlying mental disorder, said Henry. He insisted this could lead to "complete breakdowns," resulting in violence.

For that reason, he argued that no rehab center should be built near a school. "I don't think there could be a worse place," he said.

He also ridiculed Atiyeh's proposal because there "clearly" is no treatment plan in place.

When questioned about rehab centers like the Keenan House, located in Allentown, Henry responded, "I don't like to go to Allentown. It's a little dangerous."

When Attorney Malkames asked Henry whether he really believed that a DUI offender is suffering from some kind of psychosis, Henry responded, "That's an incompetent statement."

Testimony in this case will continue, and hopefully conclude, in a hearing on November 20, 6 PM, at the Bethlehem Public Library.

11 comments:

Uncle Remus said...

Who has to pay for the lawyers and administrative costs of all of these hearings?

Bernie O'Hare said...

For an appeal of this nature, I believe Atiyeh has to pay $500 to file the appeal, plus $200 for each additional night of testimony. This means this case will cost him at least $900 in filing fees.

The Zoning Officer must advertise the appeal and send out notices of the hearing. In addition. ZHB are paid a whopping $25 per night. Last night's hearing amounted to $5.55 per hour for them. They are essentially volunteers.

The Solicitor must be paid. Those fees are usually well below an attorney's usual rate. Att'y Spadoni and the zoning officer ares salaried and do not receive any additional compensation for appearing at a zoning appeal. Also, the stenographer must be paid an appearance fee. I probably missed a few things. But I would guess that the zoning appeal for 2110 Center will cost the City about $3,000, assuming it ends next month.

Just a guess on my part.

Anonymous said...

In defending the residents of Bethlehem from a preadatory developer, people support the expenditures.

Uncle Remus said...

Thanks, BO

Anonymous said...

after reading all this, I now support Abe...

Anonymous said...

Bernie, the Physcotherapist claims that Recovering Alocholics have mental problems that lead to violence. The Gracedale Goons better be careful. They don't know who they're screwing with.

Bernie O'Hare said...

No question I'm cRaZy. But this psych dude is even nuttier. What's worse, he's a tad full of himself.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

See, he just pleaded guilty to pitching an illegal tent. My column awaits...

Bill White, maybe

Bernie O'Hare said...

I love the enlightened anonymous statement about Abe Atiyeh, that I just had to delete. It's nice to know bigotry is alive and well, despite a meaningless human relations act in Bethlehem.

Anonymous said...

Hello it's me, I am also visiting this web page daily, this web page is really pleasant and the visitors are really sharing good thoughts.

Visit my webpage ... cheap carinsurance