Bethlehem Planners Ponder Sidewalks

Andrew Twiggar (L) and Olga Negron (R)

Habitat for Humanity, developer of 17-acre neighborhood called Minsi Ridge on the slopes of South Mountain, would like to be excused, at least for now, from installing sidewalks along the west side of James Street and the south side of Aaron Street. Citing the topography and remoteness of this site, located near the Sands Casino, it asked the City's Planning Commission for a deferral at their September 20 meeting. But a confused board tabled the matter, uncertain whether a deferral or outright waiver is the most appropriate solution.

"What has changed since you were last here that would justify a deferral?" asked Planning Chair Jim Fiorentino.

In 2007, plans for this development were originally rejected, although a re-submission narrowly passed.

"This is just three blocks from my house," stated Planning Commission member Olga Negron. "This is such a green area. I would like it kept green."

But Fiorentino countered that when this plan was first proposed, the objection was that the entire area should be kept green.

Another Planning Commissioner, Andrew Twiggar, noted that, unlike other subdivisions in which planners are reluctant to grant deferrals, James and Aaron Streets are not through streets and would have less pedestrian access.

But Fiorentino was still concerned that, if the City later decides it wants sidewalks, there will be confusion about who will bear the cost. Habitat for Humanity contended it would be the abutting owner. But one of those abutting owners, Wayne Yerger, disagreed. "I will be one of the people going after them," he said.

Then Fiorentino pondered whether, instead of a deferral, planners should grant an outright waiver, which would excuse everyone from installing a sidewalk.

"We're getting into things we did not anticipate at all," stated Planning Director Darlene Heller.

Bethlehem's Planning Commission decided to table the matter until their October 11 meeting and let city lawyers review the matter.