Tonight's debate between VP Joe Biden and Congressman Paul Ryan will be loved by Democrats and Republicans alike, as both candidates appealed to their bases. But what about Independents? Undecideds?
I'm posting my thoughts before all the experts tell me what I'm supposed to think. Ryan's calm and factual approach will be appreciated more than the scoffing, laughing and constant interruptions from Biden. Some of those may come back to haunt Team Obama down the road.
Substantively, I'd call it a draw. Stylistically, Biden's energy might turn people off.
Today's one-liner: “In a republican nation whose citizens are to be led by reason and persuasion and not by force, the art of reasoning becomes of first importance.” T Jefferson
Showing posts with label Paul Ryan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Paul Ryan. Show all posts
Thursday, October 11, 2012
Thursday, April 07, 2011
Is Ryan's Budget Proposal a Solution or Starting Point?
Is Rep. Paul Ryan's budget proposal, which eliminates Medicare as an entitlement while simultaneously ending the top individual tax rate from 35% to 25%, a good or a bad thing? Incoming DNC chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz has already called the Wisconsin Republican's proposal a “death trap for seniors.” Fiscal Commission and Moment of Truth project co-chairs Erskine Bowles and former Sen. Alan Simpson offer qualified praise, but claim it falls short in cutting defense spending. Most important of all, they warn that it will never achieve the broad bipartisan support necessary to be successful. That was the problem with the Health Care Overhaul. Instead of moving by consensus, sweeping legislation was just jammed down the throats of an unwilling public, who reacted at the polls.
That pendulum swings both ways.
At first blush, Ryan's proposal strikes me as an insulting attempt to balance the budget on the backs of those who can least afford it, mostly the working poor. But his changes to Medicare might be worth considering.
As explained by Slate's Jacob Weisberg, "Ryan's vouchers should provide excellent coverage. His change would amount to a minor amendment to the social contract, not a fundamental revision of it."
I'm all for a new austerity, but the pain needs to be shared. Instead of just the working poor, the "job creators" (who have not been creating much of anything) need to start tightening their belts, too.
While stopping short of an outright endorsement, LV Congressman Charlie Dent released a statement that appears to view Ryan's proposal as a first step.
“Chairman Ryan has produced a serious and sobering document that recognizes our unsustainable budget trajectory and offers remedies that will control excessive government spending, reduce the national debt and support economic growth. Chairman Ryan’s proposal stands in stark contrast to the lack of leadership displayed by the Obama Administration in the release of its Fiscal Year 2012 budget request, which fails to address excessive federal spending.
“I look forward to the crucial conversations this budget proposal will stimulate in the 15th District and across the United States. Our country is facing a spending driven debt crisis and Chairman Ryan’s proposal to reduce non-security discretionary spending to below 2008 levels, while freezing spending for five years, is an important step toward stabilizing our nation’s fiscal situation.
“Chairman Ryan has also outlined proposals aimed at ensuring the long-term sustainability of our national safety net programs for our children and grandchildren, as well as protecting the health and retirement security of those near retirement and retirees currently receiving benefits. These proposals are transformational and deserve thoughtful review."
Chairman Ryan’s FY12 budget proposal brings government spending under 20% of GDP by 2015; reduces the national debt by $4.7 trillion over the next decade; and simplifies the tax code and provides tax relief to encourage sustainable economic growth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)