About Me

My photo
Nazareth, Pa., United States

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

McClure and Zrinski Spar Over Budget

Northampton County Exec Tara Zrinski is Lamont McClure's hand-picked successor. He recruited her to run when he decided against seeking a third term. He also contributed heavily to her campaign. As a County Council member, she never opposed any of his initiatives, no matter how unpopular they might be with the rest of Council. But after winning the Exec race, a small streak of independence began to assert itself. She raised concerns about his 2026 budget, but still backed most of his agenda, including a tax break for luxury apartments. She approved McClure's hire as an Assistant County Solicitor and followed his agenda in a spat McClure had with DA Steve BarattaShe continued singing the praises of Gracedale Administrator Michelle Morton, even as the nursing home's license was continually downgraded. But cracks in their relationship began to appear as she made numerous remarks about putting out fires left by the previous administration and complained about the low wages paid to county employees. After she announced her budget and a whopping 43% tax increase, McClure argued she had gone too far. Even after she cut her original proposal by more than half, McClure has said it's too much. Below are the (rather lengthy arguments both have made on Facebook:

McClure's take:  On Friday we received the welcome news that County Executive Zrinski is asking County Council to amend her proposal. This will have the effect of reducing the tax increase from 43.5% to 20.4%. It means the proposed millage rate increase is now 2.2 mils as opposed to the original 4.71. It is still way too high, but several County Council Members have authored amendments of their own. If most, if not all of the amendments pass, the ultimate increase will be closer to 1 mil than to almost 5 mils proposed. After the original proposal was issued, I discussed in a post you can read below, how and why we made the budgetary decisions we made. I also said I’d talk more about the 2022 tax cut in a future post. We’ve saved the real estate property taxpayers of Northampton County over 40 million dollars over the last 4 years, and it’s not lost on me, that the budgeteers at the County were trying to claw all of that revenue back in one budget. What follows is my view of what is really going on, and it has less to do with the new spending the Executive wants to do than you might think.

First, I wasn’t just County Executive for 8 years, I also served on County Council for almost a decade. By my count, I had a hand in 18 County budgets - one year as Chairman of Council’s Finance Committee.
Second, I had come to learn very early in my time on Council, that it had become the habit of County government to keep $100,000,000.00 of taxpayer funds in a fund balance. This was a bipartisan consensus supported by both Democratic and Republican County Executives and the most conservative and liberal members of County Council. A fund balance is what it sounds like. It’s a fund of revenue collected and received that is not anticipated to be spent in that budget year. These are sometimes referred to as budgetary reserves. The fund has two components. A restricted component and an unrestricted component which is exactly what it sounds like.
Third, local governments are subject to generally accepted governmental accounting practices. (GASB). These standards do not have the force of law, but are generally adhered to as failure to do so can have consequences for your bond rating and getting you re-elected. These standards require you to have 2 months of budgetary reserves off of your general fund. As you can see, a 100 million dollar fund balance on a 100 million dollar general fund is a good bit more than 2 months of reserves. (It’s important to remember that more than 2/3 of any PA County’s budget is pass through money from the State and Federal governments and not revenue raised from the County millage rate.)
Fourth, of the $100,000,000.00 of your money they kept hanging onto, 60 million of it was unrestricted and the other 40 million restricted.
Fifth, while on Council I came to see the situation as wrong. Overtaxing our citizens so we could keep their money in our own interest bearing accounts year after year was not good government.
Sixth, as it was wrong to collect more revenue than we knew we’d need to operate the government, and that we were exceeding the accounting standards by mile, I tried to cut the millage rate five or six times, I’ve lost count, while on County Council. But, like I said, there was a powerful bipartisan consensus to take more of your money than we needed and to collect interest on it. I often couldn’t get a second for my proposal. However, the Hon. Tom Dietrich seconded my motion once or twice as did the Honorable Ken Kraft. Even in those years, we only managed 2 votes for cutting taxes.
Seventh, after having been there through the financial collapse of 2008-2009, which was complicated by the County’s entanglement with a financial instrument known as a Swaption, and through the economic destruction caused by the Covid-19 pandemic, I’d noticed something. No matter how bad things got during the Great Recession or in the COVID Collapse, that unrestricted fund balance rarely dropped below 60 million dollars. As noted previously, this was a bipartisan agreement between the Branches and the Parties.
Eighth, the only time it did drop under 60 million was the year I was Finance Chair. I got it down to 50 million. Guess who wasn’t Finance Chair ever again.
Ninth, there was only one way I was going to change this pattern and that was to get elected County Executive. I started that project in earnest in 2013.
Tenth, when we finally arrived in 2018, we passed 3 no tax increase budgets, and I noticed something. Even I, was keeping more of your money than we needed to run the government.
Eleventh, when we were doing the 2022 budget, I wanted to cut the tax rate by 1 mil. My predecessor John Brown and his Republican controlled County Council raised it 1 mil in 2015. I made the case to my colleagues at the time that it was unnecessary to do it, and I begged Mr. Brown to veto it. In the end, they did it because they wanted to maintain a 100,000,000.00 fund balance. I experienced internal resistance to my tax cut proposal, and I heard all of the same arguments that I heard during all of my time on Council.
Twelfth, our tax cut worked. It has saved real estate property taxpayers in Northampton County 40 million dollars. The County now only keeps two months of your money in the budgetary fund balance in combination with County Council’s Stabilization Fund. Our external, independent audits have all comeback clean with respect to our fund balance policy, and we had no trouble borrowing money last year despite that policy and the fact we had a recent tax cut. (Bond rating agencies don’t like tax cuts, and we were still rated AA1.)
Finally, if this year’s tax increase is anywhere near 2 mils or above, you’ll be back to $100,000,000.00 fund balances in less than 3 years. I think you should keep more of that money in your bank account - not the County’s.

Zrinski's rebuttal: Residents deserve a clear accounting of this budget: what it funds, why costs have increased, and what the alternatives would require. Mr. McClure’s recent statement makes that accounting necessary.

My predecessor, who encouraged me to seek this office and subsequently served in the Solicitor’s Office, had the opportunity to bring his concerns directly to this administration and help develop solutions. He has instead chosen to make his case publicly. His arguments should therefore be measured against the obligations he left behind.

Mr. McClure takes responsibility for “eight budgets,” then suggests Council could have raised taxes, while acknowledging that he “would have vetoed it.” Those positions are difficult to reconcile. Council cannot reasonably be faulted for failing to enact a measure he says he would have blocked.

Fiscal responsibility is measured by more than the tax rate. It also means paying employees fairly, honoring retirement commitments, maintaining public property, and funding the services residents rely on. A tax bill does not show whether those obligations have been met. Eventually, the County’s finances do.

Consider the obligations this administration must now address:

- Retirement: The 2026 budget includes $1.28 million because this administration added it. The actuarially determined County contribution is approximately $12 million, reflecting, in part, four previous cost-of-living adjustments that were amortized rather than fully funded under Mr. McClure’s budgets. These obligations were not created by this administration. They became ours to address.

- Retiree healthcare: The 2026 budget includes no contribution toward retiree other post-employment benefits, or OPEB. The proposed 2027 contribution is $1.52 million.

- Public assets: The 2026 County contribution was $410,000, reflecting what remained in OSI, with no allocations for Farmland Preservation or Parks and Recreation.

- Public improvements: No funding was budgeted for public improvements. This administration had to identify money for urgent maintenance and repairs, including a roof that blew off at Gracedale and a collapsed pipe at the jail. The proposed 2027 budget includes $3.78 million for documented needs, including fire-alarm replacement, jail wall repairs, and Gracedale sewer repairs.

Deferred maintenance does not disappear. It becomes the next administration’s repair bill and the public’s expense.

Mr. McClure has explained that holding taxes steady helped residents manage inflation. The concern is real albeit incomplete because inflation also affects the County’s cost of providing services, just as it affects household budgets.

Employee healthcare and dental contributions are increasing by $2.68 million, with vision and prescription contributions increasing by another $2.26 million. We also face retention challenges at the jail, Gracedale, and the Sheriff’s Department, where low starting salaries make it harder to retain and hire employees. These are the services the County provides that are at stake not just the employees. County employees are taxpayers, too. Holding down their compensation does not eliminate a cost but asks them to bear it in the same economic circumstances.

Mr. McClure’s administration also received $61.3 million in pandemic assistance, as well as opioid settlement funding. Those resources belong in any fair assessment of the financial circumstances during his tenure. He navigated an unprecedented Pandemic and for that, I have always given him credit. That does not explain away, however, the County’s recurring obligations.

I raised concerns about the proposed 2026 budget and urged Council to address its shortcomings. I also supported Mr. McClure’s budgets while serving on Council. Both are part of my record, and I will not ask residents to overlook either.
Mr. McClure is entitled to oppose this proposal. But a credible alternative must do more than reject the revenue. It must identify which obligations would go unfunded, which projects would be delayed, which services would be reduced, or which other revenues would pay the bills.

If his alternative relies on reserves or borrowing, he should state the amounts, the purposes, and how those choices would be sustained. The County’s Aa1 bond rating is an asset to protect, not a substitute for a plan to meet recurring expenses.

The appropriate comparison is not between this proposal and a past tax bill. It is between this proposal and an alternative for 2027.

I will own this administration’s proposal, including the difficult choices it asks residents to make. I will have proposed specific, workable alternatives that don’t magically erase the obligations but buffer them with graduated payments. What I will not do is describe an unfunded obligation as a saving simply because payment was left to a successor.

Mr. McClure’s record deserves the same scrutiny as my proposal, not only what taxpayers paid during his tenure, but what remained to be paid when it ended. One can only kick the can down the road so many years.

Holding the line is an accomplishment only if the obligations on the other side of it have been met. That is the standard this budget must meet and the standard by which the budgets before it should be judged.

We are in the same team, and I don’t mean democratic. We should be looking out for what is in the best interest of the County. Taking credit for holding the line is easy. Accepting responsibility for what was left on the other side of that line is the test of leadership. This isn’t political, it’s math.

No comments:

Post a Comment

You own views are appreciated, especially if they differ from mine. But remember, commenting is a privilege, not a right. I will delete personal attacks or off-topic remarks at my discretion. Comments that play into the tribalism that has consumed this nation will be declined. So will comments alleging voter fraud unless backed up by concrete evidence. If you attack someone personally, I expect you to identify yourself. I will delete criticisms of my comment policy, vulgarities, cut-and-paste jobs from other sources and any suggestion of violence towards anyone. I will also delete sweeping generalizations about mainstream parties or ideologies, i.e. identity politics. My decisions on these matters are made on a case by case basis, and may be affected by my mood that day, my access to the blog at the time the comment was made or other information that isn’t readily apparent.