O'Hare's WWII Diary: Half-Starved Soldier Worries About Brother in South Pacific

This is the latest installment from my dad's short-lived diary, penned shortly after his release from a German POW camp. In these entries, my eighty pound and half-starved father worries about his brother, Art, who was then serving in the South Pacific.

Uncle Art was wounded shortly after my father's posts, but not seriously. He was shot in the ass. When I once questioned him about it many years later, he snarled, "I was in front of the front lines, going for extra ammunition."

That's about all he ever shared. He kept no diary. He drank a lot, too.
5/20/45

All of my equipment, loot, real and personal property was once again in moving order waiting to be donned on my aching back as soon as the order to move was given. I waited and waited, a practice at which I have become very adept, for hour upon hour but no such order came. As we were lined up for midday chow ten G.I. trucks pulled up as only G.I. trucks can and I thought that this day would at last see me back to our own lines. However, due to the absence of certain documents or some such reason we are again detained by the Russians. I'm becoming a firm believer in the Vonnegut statement that "getting out of Germany is like walking in sand." The rumor now seems to be that we will pull out tomorrow when the trucks return with the proper papers. More of Hq. Co. showed up today in the persons of Sgt. Shuve and Pfc Sabbatino. Both look OK except for the loss of weight common to all POW's. Neither could give me any info regarding the whereabouts of Sgt. Boyle, Heinbeck, or Edgeworth. I'd certainly enjoy seeing those boys again.

The war in the Pacific seems to be progressing favorably, although we are meeting stiff resistance on some of the islands. I have an uncomfortable feeling that I'll learn more of that phase of our international troubles through first-hand experience. I'd like to see that part of the world but it would be just my luck to accomplish the feat through the medium of being a POW of the Japs, and twice in a lifetime is too much. The Russian band serenaded us again tonight. I'm getting to really like Russian music. The Russians are very much like Americans in their outlook on life. I suppose that is what queers the English with them. A few of us went across the hall to where we had discovered a radio in the room of one of our comrades. We listened for a while and left being driven out by static and by the system the joker in charge was using to operate the darn thing. He's one of that particular species of mankind who thinks he's operating the blue network whenever he comes across a radio with more than two dials on it. We are now preparing for bed at the end of a rather uneventful day.

5/21/45

Lo and behold I am still in Riesa. No trucks appeared today or had been rumored. However, we did receive a visit from two chaplains - one Protestant and one Catholic. They both held services and I heard mass and received communion for the first time in five months. The chaplain who was from the 69th division claimed that we would be out of here in three or four days. He seemed pretty confident that we would be back in the states within a few weeks after we hit our own lines. My inbred scepticism [sic] prohibits me from placing too much stock in his optimistic statement. Time and time alone will tell. The chaplains also brought some V-mail along with them. I wrote to my parents and to Aunt Mae. The letters are supposed to be on their way, having been brought back to our own lines with the chaplain who left here seven o'clock this evening.

5/22/45

A very routine day. I slept through reveille and all the morning, arising only for breakfast. Most of the afternoon was spent by all of us chewing the rag in the room where we were assembled. I thought of home today. Nothing now seems more welcome than news of the family. I am worried especially about Art. I certainly hope he has been as lucky as I in regard to ducking bullets and artillery.

It is early evening now and all of us are in the room now writing, reading, playing cards and talking. Things will no doubt continue along the same line until bed time. Blogger's Note: First published 12/17/07.

NorCo Council Race Update:

In late November, I told you that the terms of five at-large seats on NorCo Council will expire at the end of next year. Those five members are elected countywide as opposed to a specific geographic area. The five current at-large members are Council President Lori Vargo Heffner, VP Ron Heckman, John Brown, John Goffredo and Jeff Corpora. None has announced plans to seek another term. If they do, they'll have company. Those who are interested in seeking a position include Nadeem Qayyum (announced), Tom Gilmour (Facebook page), Patti Bruno, Leslie Altieri, Wind Gap Borough Council member Jason Boulette (announced) and union leader Paul Anthony.

"If Lori runs for council - I will challenge her. You can quote that," says Patti Bruno, who in 2021 finished 7th of 10 candidates for 5 seats. Lori Vargo Heffner finished 2d. 

Siegel Definitely Running For LeHi Co Exec

Earlier this month, I told you that State Rep. Josh Siegel intended to run for county exec in Lehigh. He's relying heavily on support (and lots of money) from the trade unions, but you'll see nothing from firefighters or police, whom he alienated during his brief tenure as a member of Allentown City Council. According to Lehigh Valley News, he's now made it official. That's no surprise, but I am disappointed to see that he already has the backing of incumbent Phil Armstrong. He knows better. Siegel is a carbon copy of Controller Mark Pinsley, who stands for partisanship and divisiveness. 

Lehigh County at one time was more Republican than NorCo, but that has changed. Unless a decent Democrat or a viable Republican announces, he's going to win on a platform of walkability and amenities. Translation: build, build, build. 

NorCo Judges Want Witnesses in Former Custody Master's Federal Lawsuit to ID Themselves on Criminal Arraignment Day

Yesterday was arraignment day in Northampton County Courtroom #1. That's our historic and ceremonial courtroom, with portraits of scowling dead judges littered along the walls between colossal windows and a ceiling that rivals the Tower of Babel in size. The well of the court has plush carpeting and a mammoth mahogany bench for the court en banc, although there are now more judges than room for them all to sit there together. There's an ornate jury box with cushioned chairs. The well also includes a ring of cushioned chairs and a few benches at which lawyers can be seated. Everyone else is an untouchable and must sit in one of many hard wooden pews that make their way from the well to the back. It's very much like a church, except the priesthood consists of judges and lawyers. When a robed judge marches in, everyone must rise until told they may be seated. During yesterday's arraignment, 33 pages of criminal defendants were formally notified of charges against them and were asked how they intend to plead.  It's a cattle call but can be very intimidating for people stepping foot inside a courtroom for the first time. Yesterday's call of the list (which is what arraignments are called) may have been intimidating for some lawyers as well. 

Judge Sam Murray handled yesterday's arraignment. But instead of starting off by calling the names of the numerous defendants, he had an announcement. At the request of the President Judge, he wanted two people who are named as witnesses in a federal lawsuit to identify themselves. 

This federal lawsuit in question is a civil rights action filed by former custody master Lissa Tresslar on April 5 against Northampton County Court alleging wrongful termination and retaliatory actions for her free speech in criticizing the way that custody matters were being handled. That matter is currently in discovery. 

Tresslar is currently employed as an assistant District Attorney, but her role insulates both her and the courts. She handles the numerous appeals before the Superior and Supreme Court and thus has no contact with the county judges. 

But yesterday, perhaps in an abundance of caution, the courts wanted two witnesses in Tresslar's lawsuit to identify themselves. Those two witnesses, like Tresslar, happen to be prosecutors. One of them was "devastated" after being publicly outed. Some attorneys, who themselves are potential witnesses, delt this was an attempt by the courts to intimidate them and make them less reluctant to testify.

More likely, the court was simply trying to determine if there are situations in which an individual judge assigned to a matter involving that lawyer might feel compelled to recuse himself or herself. 

Frankly, I fail to see how a lawyer's involvement as a fact witness in a wrongful termination lawsuit has any bearing at all on the administration of criminal justice. Moreover, it appears that the court could easily have applied less intrusive methods of establishing who may have knowledge of facts in a totally unrelated matter. This could easily be accomplished via colloquies on the record between the judge, prosecuting attorney, defense attorney and defendant. There was no need to bring this out in a courtroom filled with hundreds of people. 

Unfortunately, I do not have the transcript of what occurred and am going by reports from third parties. I'll have more details when I review it. 

Basically, I find no fault with the court's attempt to determine whether there is a need for recusal. I just think it went about it with a buzzsaw. 

O'Hare's WWII Diary: Still No Word About Dresden Firebombing

This is the second in a series of entries from my father's recently-discovered dairy. He kept it about a week after his release from a German POW camp. This second post, like the first, is strictly present tense. Yet just three months before, my dad and writer Kurt Vonnegut had ringside seats, as POWs, to the American and RAF firebombing of Dresden - Florence of the Elbe.

POWs hid in meat lockers underneath a slaughterhouse during this incineration. One POW blurted out, "I wonder what the poor people are doing tonight." I can't help but think that was my dad. That was his humor.

In a public radio interview, Vonnegut speaks of a conversation he had with my father, some twenty years later.

"What did you learn?" Vonnegut asks.

"I will never believe my government again."

Churchill, who had advocated the firebombing, was knighted.

5/18/45

We moved over to the other compound today. That seems to be the chief benefit accruing to those who have been deloused. The rooms here are much cleaner and better equipped. We eat three times per day restaurant style and the shilly (chile?) is both good and thick - a happy set of circumstances not found readily in Germany. We spent most of the day getting our loot in order and this afternoon learned to our gratification that we were scheduled to move out. About an hour later a sergeant from the 1st Rangers division put in an appearance and announced that trucks were on their way to bring us either to Riesa or Leipzig where there are concentrations of former P.O.W.'s. I had no idea the sight of a G.I. would be so sensational. Needless to say, the limeys hogged him before any of his own countrymen had a chance to learn much from him concerning the good old U.S.A. Well, the trucks finally arrived and after the normal red tape we piled into them and took off. Approximately two hours later we found ourselves in Riesa. Temporary quarters were provided for us in some Jerry barracks. We are supposed to move in the morning to some other place in town where there are more G.I.'s. Our present barracks aren't at all bad except for the lack of anything soft upon which to lay our weary bones. There are some limeys here who have been waiting to get out for almost a month. It seems that Stalag W-B was liberated by the Russians on April 23.
Blogger's Note: This was originally published on 12/12/07.

The Oligarchs Among Us

Elon Musk holds no elected office. Yet House Speaker Mike Johnson is hopping like a scared rabbit after Musk voiced opposition to a continuing resolution to fund the government. When we speak of oligarchs, we tend to think of Slavic billionaires, who call the shots from their dachas in Sochi. But there are an increasing number of American oligarchs on both the left and right ends of the political spectrum. They are far more dangerous to American democracy than some poor bastard who fails to get the necessary papers before he moves here. 

O'Hare's WWII Diary: "We are Being Looked After Like Pet Children by the Russians"

Writer Kurt Vonnegut's letter home, written soon after his release from a POW camp, was published here yesterday*. Believe it or not, my dad was the real writer back then - he even kept a diary for an entire week.

Unlike Vonnegut, he sheds no light on what had actually happened to him as a POW. He provides no explanation about his weight going from 150 lbs. before the war to 80 lbs. as Adolph's guest. Mum's the word. He'd stay like that the rest of his life. Vonnegut's three-page letter tells me more about my dad's POW experience than he himself ever shared.

He just drank. A lot. Especially at Christmas time. That didn't kill him. Neither did the Germans. The cigarettes did.

But for one week, my father chronicled his post-release experiences in amazing detail. Just twenty-two at the time, he was a pretty good writer himself. Occasionally, he mentions Vonnegut, who was just a "minor being" at the time. For the next few days, I'll share my dad's thoughts with you, day by day.

5/17/45

Our mangy but well-fed crew left DiHille's at noon today. We proceeded over the Elbe to Russian headquarters in the city and after much confusion - due to our ignorance of the Russian language and vice versa - we were directed to the Hitler Caserne on Konigsbage Strasse. Here we find ourselves confronted with the perpetual situation of no one knowing anything about anything. However, we are being looked after like pet children by the Russians. We have been here only four hours at the most and have already been fed twice, showered, de-loused and billeted. As near as we can gather from speaking to the limeys and G.I.'s here, we are to stay put until our troops come seeking us. Except for the anxiety that we all have concerning our parents and families, we don't give a damn how long it takes them to root us out.

I heard my first radio program since I was captured. Dannine and I went across the compound and fell in with a few Tommies who have a wireless set in their flat. We heard an A.M.G. broadcast from Hamburg. That American music certainly sounded good. The Tommies surprised us before the evening was over with a meal of spuds, meat and beans. We rejoined our crew with a full stomach and a highly satisfied mien. I don't believe I'll ever get up out of bed again. Goot nacht.

*) Vonnegut's letter home will be published here on Christmas Eve, 

A Modest Plan to Retain NorCo County Workers and Provide Workforce Housing

Over the past year, there's been no shortage of stories about the need for affordable housing. This was even an issue in this year's Presidential race. This is a problem that was actually created back in 2008, when the Great Recession resulted in a collapse of construction. That industry is still only a shadow of its former self. But even with a booming construction industry, many cities like those in the Lehigh Valley have very limited space on which to build and can only do so much. County governments, and perhaps some townships, can do more. Aside from its own courthouse and Gracedale campus, Northampton County owns 500 acres of land. Instead of leasing it to farmers, couldn't some of this land be used to create affordable housing? Better yet, couldn't some of it be used to provide affordable housing to county employees who are increasingly difficult to retain?

Northampton County has about 1700-1800 employees, though its actual number should be closer to 2,000. It has problems attracting nursing care at Gracedale, despite offering retention bonuses and even building a daycare that may or may not yet be open. This is a nationwide problem, and the county has been forced to hire outside nurses to provide care at higher rates than it pays its own. 

In addition to a shortage of nursing care at Gracedale, there is also a shortage of corrections officers, youth care workers and 911 dispatchers. They are often forced to work overtime to fill gaps in coverage, which exhausts them and can make conditions unsafe. 

Couldn't we express our appreciation to these unsung heroes by providing them with an affordable place to live?

Here's what I would suggest as a pilot program. The Gracedale campus is huge. Some of that land is used neither for farming nor anything else. It's just grass to cut. How about a small development of about 30 homes for workers in critical departments like the jail, Gracedale, Juvenile Justice Center and 911. I'm not speaking of McMansions but am thinking of smaller homes like the Boxable Casita. 

The county could offer these homes and agree to hold the mortgage at a low interest rate. The qualifying employee would own, not rent the property to erase any illusion that this is a company store. If the employee either leaves county employment or decides to sell the property for a larger home, the county would have an option to repurchase at its appraised market value. That way the employee could build equity, and the county could attract and retain good workers. 

What do you think of this idea? Any suggestions to make it better? Is it nonsense? 

O'Hare Describes WWII Firing Squad: "German Justice Taking Its Usual Course . . ."

As time marches on, we are slowly forgetting what military historian Charles B. MacDonald has called "the greatest battle ever fought by the United States Army." The soldiers who fought in it are dying at the rate of 1,000 per day, and with them their history.

Unlike the talkative baby boomers in my generation - with our cell phones, the Internet and blogs - the soldiers of that Greatest Generation are strangely quiet and modest. They managed to save the world from a real Axis of Evil in spite of being caught late and off guard, and then went to work to make our own lives easy.

Although our memory is dimming, Blue Coyote tells us that in some portions of Europe, Americans are still considered "prima." The people of Bastogne still remember.

In his diary, my father never discussed what had actually happened during his captivity as a POW. Below you will find the only instance in which he speaks about the war. It's a letter he sent to the War Department in 1947, responding to an inquiry about one of his fellow POWs who never came home.

In reply to your letter of the 14th inst., I beg to express my regrets that you were required to make two inquiries concerning the above-noted matter. The receipt of your first letter was never called to my attention or you would most certainly have received a more prompt response.

Pfc. Michael Palaia and myself were sent with a detachment of American soldier-prisoners from Stalag IV-B to Dresden, Germany. After Dresden was bombed (about Feb. 14th, 1945), it became necessary for our captors to remove us to a new section of the City which, although not quite, was practically in the suburbs. It required climbing a rather steep hill to reach this place, from the summit of which it was possible to see practically the whole city. At the base of the hill was a moderate-sized street car barn and also a building in which German prisoners were hospitalized. I mention all of this as it may be necessary for you to fix the location of this place, and it is the only way I have of describing it, never having known the name of the section. Dresden is divided by the Elbe River and the section to which I have reference was on the eastern side thereof.

Our work after the bombing consisted wholly of cleaning cellars of their casualties and streets of their refuse. Our food ration per day was very low and survival made it necessary to pilfer food from cellars in which it was found from time to time. Unfortunately, Pfc. Palaia was discovered while doing this and at the time of the discovery one jar of string beans was found on his person. His number (prisoner number) was taken by the guard. The very next day when we had lined up ready to march to work, Pfc. Palaia was taken from our ranks by the German in charge - his official title being to the best of my recollection "Feldwabel." When we returned from work that night we learned that he was on trial for his life. Naturally, German justice taking its usual course, he was found guilty and four days after his apprehension he was killed by a firing squad. Four of our fellow-prisoners had witnessed this shooting, identified his body, dug his grave and buried him.

The shooting took place at some German military installation which, from the witnesses' reports was from five to seven miles from the location of our barracks. It must have been in a general westerly direction therefrom as I recall their stating that on their way they had crossed the river Elbe. I am not positive in my recollection of this, but I believe they also stated that they had constructed a cross for his grave to which they attached his dog tag.

The Month of his death was march, I am certain, and March the l6th, I believe. One of the witnesses was a Frank Terterici from Boston, Mass. I have a record somewhere of at least one of the other witnesses and his address. I will forward this information yo you as soon as I am able to locate same.

I hope the above account will be of some aid to you. Please have no hesitation in making further inquiry if you deem it feasible.

Asking your pardon for not having replied sooner, I am

Very truly yours,

B.V. O'Hare, Jr.

Retail Theft Up 53% in Pa. Between 2021 and 2023

A news release from Pennsylvania courts indicates retail theft has risen 53% between 2021 and 2023. While this crime is usually associated with high school kids, the data show that 29% of all offenders are between 26 and 35 years old.  

Whether this is a national trend sparked by inflation is unknown. According to the Brennan Center for Justice, shoplifting has increased dramatically in New York City and Los Angeles but has actually declined over the past four years across 24 cities. 

Increases are highest in Allegheny (13%), Montgomery (9%) and Philadelphia (6%) counties.

How about here in the Lehigh Valley. Lehigh County has seen a 2.6% increase while NorCo is only half that at 1.34%. 

The data do not distinguish between organized retail theft and shoplifting of small items by individuals for personal gain. 

I personally know two people who have some sort of compulsion to steal small items of little value. One of them has been jailed numerous times. It hasn't helped. Nor have visits to a psychologist.  

A Christmas Present From Kurt Vonnegut

A biographer has asked me for information concerning the friendship between my father and author Kurt Vonnegut. My brother, a pack rat, produced a letter that Vonnegut wrote to his own family, not long after he and my dad were released from a POW camp at the end of WWII. In many ways, this three-page letter is his first draft of Slaughterhouse Five. Vonnegut sent my family a copy of that letter, apparently as a Christmas present, in 1996.

Bewildered that he has somehow survived, the young Vonnegut tells his folks, "I've too damned much to say, the rest will have to wait." Fortunately for us, he got around to it.

This letter is too important to sit in a dusty attic, so I'm sharing it with you. If you'd like to see a pdf copy, just click this link.

Dear people:

I'm told that you were probably never informed that I was any­thing other than "missing in action." Chances are that you also failed to receive any of the letters I wrote from Germany. That leaves me a lot of explaining to do - in precis: I've been a prisoner of war since December 19th, 1944, when our division was cut to ribbons by Hitler's last desperate thrust through Luxemburg and Belgium. Seven Fanatical Panzer Divisions hit us and cut us off from the rest of Hodges' First Army. The other American Divisions on our flanks managed to pull out We were obliged to stay and fight. Bayonets aren't much good against tanks: Our ammunition, food and medical supplies gave out and our casualties out-numbered those who could still fight - so we gave up. The 106th got a Presidential Citation and some British Decoration from Mont­gomery for it, I'm told, but I'll be damned if it was worth it. I was one of the few who weren't wounded. For that much thank God.

Well, the supermen marched us, without food, water or sleep to Limberg, a distance of about sixty miles, I think, where we were loaded and locked up, sixty men to each small, unventilated, un-heated box car. There were no sanitary accommodations - the floors were covered with fresh cow dung. There wasn't room for all of us to lie down. Half slept while the other half stood. We spent several days, including Christmas, on that Limberg siding. On Christmas eve the Royal Air Force bombed and strafed our unmarked train. They killed about one-hundred-and-fifty of us. We got a little water Christmas Day and moved slowly across Germany to a large P.O.W. Camp in Muhlburg, South of Berlin. We were released from the box cars on New Year's Day. The Germans herded us through scalding delousing showers. Many men died from shock in the showers after ten days of starvation, thirst and exposure. But I didn't.

Under the Geneva Convention, Officers and Non-commissioned Officers are not obliged to work when taken prisoner. I am, as you know, a Private. One-hundred-and-fifty such minor beings were shipped to a Dresden work camp on January 10th. I was their leader by virtue of the little German I spoke. It was our misfortune to have sadistic and fanatical guards. We were refused medical atten­tion and clothing: We wore given long hours at extremely hard labor. Our food ration was two-hundred-and-fifty grams of black bread and one pint of unseasoned potato soup each day. After desperately trying to improve our situation for two months and having been met with bland smiles I told the guards just what I was going to do to them when the Russians came. They beat me up a little. I was fired as group leader. Beatings were very small time: - one boy starved to death and the SS Troops shot two for stealing food.

On about February 14th the Americans came over, followed by the R.A.F. their combined labors killed 250,000 people in twenty-four hours and destroyed all of Dresden - possibly the world's most beautiful city. But not me.

After that we were put to work carrying corpses from Air-Raid shelters; women, children, old men; dead from concussion, fire or suffocation. Civilians cursed us and threw rocks as we carried bodies to huge funeral pyres in the city.

When General Patton took Leipzig we were evacuated on foot to [...] the Checkoslovakian border. There we remained until the war ended. Our guards deserted us. On that happy day the Russians were intent on mopping up isolated outlaw resistance in our sector. Their planes (P-39's) strafed and bombed us, killing fourteen, but not me.

Eight of us stole a team and wagon. We traveled and looted our way-through Sudetenland and Saxony for eight days, living like kings. The Russians are crazy about Americans. The Russians picked us up in Dresden. We rode from there to the American lines at Halle in Lend-Lease Ford trucks. We've since been flown to Le Havre.

I'm writing from a Red Cross Club in the Le Havre P.O.W. Repat­riation Camp. I'm being wonderfully well fed and entertained. The state-bound ships are jammed, naturally, so I'll have to be patient. I hope to be home in a month. Once home I'll be given twenty-one days recuperation at Atterbury, about $600 back pay and - get this - sixty (60) days furlough!

I've too damned much to say, the rest will have to wait. I can't receive mail here so don't write. May 29, 1945

First published 12/10/07.

Have You Seen Any Drones?

I spend an average of two hours outside nearly every day, sometimes on local streets and others along trails and wooded areas. I see wildlife nearly every day, from deer to foxes and racoons. I've also been sprayed by skunks multiple times over the years, thanks to an inquisitive black lab who accompanies me when I'm on foot instead of on a bike. I see plenty of hawks and buzzards. I've even had too brief encounters with a bear. But I'm embarrassed to say I've never seen a bald eagle or a coyote, though I know they're out there. At night, I occasionally like to step outside to look at the stars or watch for northern lights on those rare occasions when they are in the forecast. I've never seen them. And unlike many local people on Facebook, I have yet to see a single drone in the sky at night. Like bald eagles and coyotes, I'm sure they are out there. But I've yet to see one flying in Nazareth airspace at night. Have you?

Red Cat CEO Jeff Thompson, whose company supplies sophisticated drone technology to the US Military, told ABC News that he doubts they come from our adversaries because they are using proper FAA lighting to display their presence, making it way too easy to shoot them down. He said they are too large to be consumer drones but it's not his company so stop calling him, lol. 

Thompson adds that all drones are required to have a remote ID, and you can download a free app like Drone Scanner to determine of the required ID is being broadcast if you spot one. I have downloaded this app but have so far have nothing. 

Because these sightings are at night, when your eyes play tricks with you, I believe that some people might be mistaking planes as drones. So contrary to some suggestions, it would be both reckless and irresponsible to shoot down what might turn out to be a plane. 

It would also be irresponsible. 

I'd agree, however, that more transparency from President Joe Biden's administration is needed if he decided to take a break from commuting the sentences of corrupt judges. 

Here's what Judge John Morganelli has to say, in his capacity as a citizen: "What I find incredible is that our military can identify a specific target , FROM OUTER SPACE, such as a terrorist sitting in his car in the middle of Afghanistan, and send a rocket from space to instantly eliminate the target, but they have no idea of the source of a drone in plain sight over NJ!! I don’t think so!"

Another Disgraceful Pardon

President Joe Biden certainly tarnished his own legacy when he pardoned his son after repeated pledges that he would do no such thing. In addition to the dishonesty, he has opened the door for President-elect Donald Trump to issue all kinds of pre-emptive pardons of his own. But as bad as that is, it's nothing compared to his decision to commute the 17 1/2 year sentence of a corrupt Luzerne County judge - Michael Conahan - who disproportionately sentenced juveniles to private detention centers in exchange for cash. Because of the pandemic, Conahan was serving his sentence at home. This decision drew criticism from Pa Gov. Josh Shapiro, who said that Biden "got it absolutely wrong and created a lot of pain here in northeastern Pennsylvania." I'm sure that pain will be felt by Democrats in the next election. It's hard to claim you believe in law and order when you allow a corrupt judge who accepted millions for sending kids to a private jail to roam free.

Over Past 10 Years, Bethlehem Has Cut Debt Nearly in Half

Many years ago, I sat in the conference room of then Bethlehem Mayor John Callahan's office. With the sun basking behind him, he told me that he was working hard to reduce the City's long-term debt. He was spending money that could be used for many other things in what essentially is a fiscally conservative move. I thought this was a pipe dream. Even if Callahan focused on reducing long-term debt, which no one really notices, his successors would quickly borrow to avoid tax hikes. But they didn't. Bob Donchez and Willie Reynolds, who followed Callahan, have continued this commitment to debt reduction. 

Over the past 10 years, Bethlehem's long-term debt has gone from $171 million in 2015 to $88.5 million today. Mayor Reynolds plans to knock it down even more, to $56 million by 2028.

Let me remind you that Reynolds, Donchez and Callahan are all Democrats. But this kind of fiscal conservatism is worthy of Elon Musk, Vibek Ramaswamy and anyone who considers himself a Republican. 

You can say what you will about Willie's budget or his policies as Mayor, but his commitment to reducing debt is a very positive and fiscally prudent move that benefits the city residents over time. 

I'll have more about Bethlehem's budget in the coming days.

Easton Eliminates Commuter Tax In Latest No-Tax-Hike Budget

For the 18th year in a row under Mayor Sal Panto, Easton on Wednesday evening adopted a no-tax-hike $71 million budget for next year. And Northampton County employees who work in Easton but live elsewhere will be happy to learn that this budget eliminates a controversial 1.95% commuter tax. The budget was adopted in a 6-0 vote following five budget hearings. Easton is no longer moderately distressed and thus was unable to impose a commuter tax. The property tax rate remains 24.95 mills. City residents still pay an earned income tax. 

Voting to support the budget were Mayor Sal Panto (who is actually a voting member of City Council under their Home Rule Charter, Ken Brown, James Edinger, Frank Pintabone, Crystal Rose and Roger Ruggles. 

Council member Taiba Sultana was absent for the adoption of the budget as well as a meeting the previous evening at which amendments were considered. She participated in two hearings by phone and was physically present for two of the five total budget hearings. She managed to attend a fundraiser for herself on Saturday night.

Becoming a Bethlehem Cop Is Harder Than Getting into the French Foreign Legion.

For every 100 who apply, the French Foreign Legion accepts only 10-15. But that's a snap compared to becoming a Bethlehem police officer. Bethlehem's budget calls for 170 officers, but at any given point in time, there are only 142-145 officers. So why not hire more? Bethlehem would love to but has very high standards. 

Take one of its most recent recruiting reviews of 110 applications. Of those who applied, only 52 were actually eligible. Of those 52, only 18 could pass the physical. Of those 18, only 8 made it through the written exam. Of those 8, only 1 passed the polygraph. 

Wild Leaks Secret Derogatory Info About House Member After Swearing to Confidentiality

On Monday night, I received both an email and a text message about a Hill news story that LV Congress member Susan Wild (D-Pa.) leaked derogatory information about a House Ethics Committee investigation, where she is the Ranking into former Congressman Matt Gaetz (R-Fl.). She did so after President-elect Donald Trump named him as his choice for Attorney General. 

Members of the House Ethics Committee take an oath "that I will not disclose, to any person or entity outside the Committee on Ethics, any information received in the course of my service with the Committee, except as authorized by the Committee or in accordance with its rules.”

Wild has been identified as the source of leaks that occurred, even after Gaetz withdrew from consideration. According to unnamed sources, she's admitted she's the source of the leak. And rather than face unpleasant questions about violating her oath, she shipped last week's meeting of the House Ethics Committee.

This is the kind of dishonest behavior from a person who parks in a spot reserved for the handicapped and then blows off two requests for an explanation. 

LC Comm'r Ron Beitler Seeks Good Executive Candidates in Lehigh

Lehigh County Exec Phil "Grandpa'" Armstrong is hanging it up after his term expires at the end of next year. That's unfortunate because he has been a good and bipartisan Exec who has worked with both parties to get things done. What's really sad is that the only announced candidate to succeed him is the opposite. 

That would be Josh Siegel, a former Allentown City Council member now serving as a State Rep. in what should be a Latino district. A New Jersey transplant, Siegel is an opportunist.

As a member of Allentown City Council, Siegel voted No to grants for the Allentown police department. He voted No to filling the depleted ranks of police officers. He participated in marches with felons like Hashann Batts, where "F--- the Police1" was the battle cry. He doxed then Mayor Ray O'Connell by handing out the Mayor's phone number to angry protestors. O'Connell thereafter received threats and calls for days. 

Wait, there's more. He and Controller  Mark Pinsley a fellow opportunist, promoted foisting two new taxes on the already impoverished citizens of Allentown. First, he wanted to enact a 1% increase in Lehigh County's sales tax. Any economist could tell you that a sales tax is regressive tax and is disproportionately felt by those with limited means. 

In addition to this sales tax hike, he and Pinsley wanted to enact a county-wide income tax to create districts that promote the arts. Yes, people who are already struggling in Allentown to put food on the table would have to work harder to help fund the artsy-fartsys.  

Like Pinsley, Josh has a track record of jumping between positions. Pinsley frequently focuses his attention on things that only tangentially if at all had anything to do with the duties of the office of the controller, as he did when he paraded a coterie of parents accused of child abuse before Northampton County Council . He did so to draw attention to himself and an ill-fated bid for State Senate. In some cases things that were outside the scope of what the county is responsible for. Most local politicians do have an interest in serving the common good. But there is also a type of politician constantly thinking about the next jump and looks to garner headlines accordingly. Josh and Pinsley are those types. 

Through the grapevine, I hear Siegel pushed LC Comm'r and Chair Geoff Brace out of the race with threats of leveraging his six-figure campaign war chest. Brace is well liked across the aisle for his ethical leadership, common sense pragmatism and bipartisan cooperation. These are qualities that NorCo Council Pres Lori Vargo Heffner tries to embrace, but she pays a price among more partisan Democrats. 

Siegel’s approach would bring divisiveness, similar to what we've seen out of the Lehigh County Controller’s office.

On the Republican side, there really are no viable candidates. Ss much as I like Glenn Eckhart or Dean Browning, they are retreads at a time when fresh faces are needed. Justin Simmons' name has been mentioned, but I'm unsure his record (or lack thereof) in the state house would help him. 

Sheriff Joe Hanna would be excellent but is committed to his role as Sheriff, where he’s widely respected statewide. Comm'r Ron Betler is another new face but is only in his first term and has a new business demanding his full time attention. 

Interestingly, Beitler has appealed for Exec candidates online, and I thought I'd share what he has to say: 

𝗪𝗮𝗻𝘁𝗲𝗱: 𝗟𝗲𝗵𝗶𝗴𝗵 𝗖𝗼𝘂𝗻𝘁𝘆 𝗘𝘅𝗲𝗰𝘂𝘁𝗶𝘃𝗲 𝗖𝗮𝗻𝗱𝗶𝗱𝗮𝘁𝗲𝘀

County government is often overlooked. As 1 of 9 Commissioners, we work with the Executive to manage the county. We pass budgets, ordinances and resolutions. We typically deal with non-partisan areas like health and human services, the jail, courts, farmland preservation, Cedarbrook, emergency services and county parks.

Our current group has largely avoided political squabbling and gridlock common in other government levels. In my time on the board, we’ve only had a few fundamentally ideological disagreements. Current Commissioners under the bi-partisan leadership team of Chair Geoff Brace and Vice Chair Jeffrey Dutt and Executive Phil Armstrong have mostly worked together effectively. With Phil term-limited, a new Executive will be elected next year.

The Executive oversees administration of services, drafts a (LARGE) budget, supervises departments, appoints officials, and holds the power to veto.

Currently, there’s only 1 announced candidate with a less than impressive resume. We deserve more options. We need several more qualified folks to step forward so voters have choices.

𝗪𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝗺𝗮𝗸𝗲𝘀 𝗮 𝗴𝗼𝗼𝗱 𝗘𝘅𝗲𝗰𝘂𝘁𝗶𝘃𝗲?

An Executive should excel in budgeting while recognizing taxpayers aren’t an unlimited funding source. They need to make data-driven decisions, oversee diverse departments and be strong communicators. They must collaborate with local, state and federal officials. (Phil excels at this!) Most importantly, they must build consensus while remaining transparent.

Often, the best Executives come with a business background, bringing skills like strategic planning, efficiency and financial planning. Leadership, problem-solving, and negotiation skills are crucial. Career politicians often have not cultivated these real world skillsets.

This role should be largely free from partisanship, as there isn’t a Republican or Democrat way to for example: administer programs or preserve farmland. 𝗔 𝗴𝗿𝗲𝗮𝘁 𝗲𝘅𝗲𝗰𝘂𝘁𝗶𝘃𝗲 𝗶𝘀 𝗶𝗻𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲𝗻𝘁𝗹𝘆 𝗮 𝗺𝗮𝗻𝗮𝗴𝗲𝗿. 𝗡𝗼𝘁 𝗮 𝗽𝗼𝗹𝗶𝘁𝗶𝗰𝗶𝗮𝗻.

𝗡𝘂𝘁𝘀 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗕𝗼𝗹𝘁𝘀:

This is a full-time, paid position with salary and county benefits. Terms are 4 years. Unlike many political positions, the Executive is expected to be a WORKING administrator.

Want to make a difference? Do you care about people, particularly our most vulnerable? Do you have business experience? It doesn’t matter if you’re a Republican, Democrat or Independent. We need several more qualified candidates for this position.

As Executive, you’ll have the chance to shape policies and manage our community. This is a unique opportunity to lead and work with dedicated professionals and residents. If you’re interested in this challenge, I and others want to hear from you!

You can reach Ron at ronbeitler@gmail.com

Sultana's Lawsuit Over Criticism is Frivolous Attempt to Suppress Free Speech

On Thursday, December 5, Easton City Council member Taiba Sultana filed a defamation complaint (you can read it below) against Pa Citizens PAC, a political action committee formed and funded by prominent immigration attorney Ray Lahoud. The lawsuit, filed by Allentown lawyer Matt Mobilio, is frivolous and will likely be dismissed after preliminary objections are filed and briefed. 

Sultana, incidentally, held a fundraiser and birthday bash over the weekend ... in Bethlehem. It's pretty odd that an Easton City Council member would fundraise outside of Easton. She's festooned in a tiara. 

Pa Citizens PAC was formed expressly for the purpose of opposing Sultana in a bid for state rep. That's core political speech. The PAC bought and posted campaign signs calling her "Crazy. Chaotic. Criminal." Most were torn down or defaced within hours. 

I've written extensively about Sultana. She was arrested and charged with domestic assault on July 31. The victim, her adult son, described her behavior as follows: "My mom had gotten very physical. She had slapped, punched me in my face and stomach multiple times. And continuously head butt me. It resulted in my face being injured and my face was bleeding. Also kept pulling my hair and dragging me around." 

The victim also describes prior incidents: "Threw dishes and sharp objects at me which resulted in my foot opening up. A sharp glass had been strewn inside my foot. I had been taken to the hospital and had to get stitches on my foot. Other incidents included punching my lip (it was bleeding nonstop) hitting me with random objects in bruised back and arm. She also threatened my many times with knives and has told me she is going to kill me one day.

"She has threatened me with knives. She has told me she is going to kill me in my sleep."    

After her arrest, Sultana spent a night in jail after being unable to post bail. She was ultimately admitted to ARD, a special program for first offenders in which charges are dismissed after successful completion of probation. After being accepted into the program, she claimed that “I would've preferred immediate dismissal, of course, but, like many people of color and poor people, I made the only option that was given to me to protect my family from the vicious attacks of those in power as well as keep my voice.”

On Easton City Council, she's been highly divisive. She has claimed she's the only Easton elected official who cares about the black and brown community. She has stated that the other Easton elected officials think the "black and brown community is criminal and dangerous." She also orchestrated a highly controversial cease-fire resolution concerning the war in Gaza and paraded numerous pro-Palestinian supporters to demand that Easton do something, though its fighter jets are currently inoperable. 

I could go on and on, but it's clear to me that her behavior as an elected official has been both crazy and chaotic. And she was arrested for domestic assault. In fact, her adult daughter was nabbed by state police and charged with defacing campaign signs criticizing Sultana as they watched another two of her minor children defacing them. 

Truth is a defense. Moreover, she is a public figure and needs to establish that the statements made were not only false but were made with reckless disregard of the truth. She would also need to prove that calling someone crazy, chaotic or criminal is more than opinion. This she will never be able to do. 

Sultana's lawyer, "Mad Matty" Mobilio, announced his lawsuit via news release. He is trying the case in the press, not in the courts. Other than garnering publicity for himself, his lawsuit has hardly helped Sultana. Now numerous news outlets are publishing the campaign sign she claims is so defamatory. This is what I's expect from someone who generated headlines when he posted a Facebook message telling someone, "If you support [Donald Trump], you are also a disgrace and should be hung for treason."

That sounds like Trump himself. 

Citizens PAC is represented by Easton barrister Steven Goudsouzian. Last night, he said his firm intends to defend the case vigorously and will be filing an appropriate response.

 Sultana Complaint by BernieOHare on Scribd

What Happened at Banana Factory Precinct on Election Day

There were unusually long lines at the Banana Factory precinct (Bethlehem 3N) on election day, as Lehigh students waited for hours before being able to vote. At Northampton County Council's December 5 meeting, VP of Lehigh University Democrats Jack Ciavolella described what he called a "simply unacceptable" election. What really happened?

According to Ciavolella, he dropped friends off at the precinct around 10 am, expecting them to be back around noon. They returned at 7:30 pm. He said there was a similar problem at Kirby Sports Center in Easton, where Lafayette students stood in line for hours. He also complained that in another Bethlehem voting station (1N), voters who left the line found out on their return that they were unable to vote at all after being assured by election workers that they could return. 

He said the county should have more voting machines and should also have an early voting station in Bethlehem. He also suggested that paper ballots should be available, although this solution would not really make voting quicker and might actually slow things down. He said there were only two machines. 

Not long ago, the judge of elections for Bethlehem 1N testified before President Judge Dally and said that five voters who had to leave were allowed to cast provisional ballots. And Director of Administration Nicole Pietrzak addressed the concerns raised by Ciavolella with Council. 

She stated that over the course of election day, nine additional voting machines were deployed. Two replaced machines that malfunctioned. The remaining seven went to precincts with unusually high turnout. Four of them went to Bethlehem's Banana Factory. She indicated the remaining machines went to the Kirby Sports Center and other Bethlehem precincts. 

At the Banana Factory, there were three machines, one of which failed to turn on. An ES&S tech arrived on site and recommended that the machine be swapped out. A replacement machine was in place at 11:20 am. At 12:45 pm, a fourth machine was delivered. At 1:20 pm, an addition epollbook was brought to the precinct, along with a pollworker who could operate it. At 2 pm, an additional pollworker arrived. The ES&S tech then returned to the Banana Factory and remained there until the polls closed. At 4:30 pm, another pollworker arrived. At 5 pm, a fifth machine was delivered with another pollbook. At 6 pm, yet another pollworker arrived. At 6:25 pm, two more pollworkers arrived with additional supplies. Twenty minutes later, there were three more pollworkers on site. At 7:35 pm, a sixth machine was delivered. The poll finally closed at 9:30 pm after one replacement machine and three additional voting machines. four pollbooks and 10 additional workers.  

The county supplied each precinct with one machine for every 450 expected voters. Turnout at Banana Factory was 37% higher than it was in 2016 and a whopping 87% higher than it was in 2020. "This could not have been predicted," observed Pietrzak. She also noted that the judge of elections for tht precinct, who is elected, seemed to lack the sense of urgency demanded by the situation. 

UPDATED: NorCo Council Adopts $502 Million Budget

Last night, NorCo Council adopted Exec Lamont McClure's proposed $502 million spending plan (you can see it here) for 2025. Although  Council  made a few changes, the now adopted budget maintains the same tax rate as this year. If you're a county taxpayer, this means that the current 10.8 mill tax rate will remain the same. A home assessed at $75,000 will receive a tax bill for $810. 

Under our Home Rule Charter, a balanced budget is required. Total proposed spending may not exceed anticipated revenue. 

McClure's $502 million spending plan is $51 million less (9.3%) than it was last year. Interestingly, only $104.4 million of the county's budget (20.9%) comes from real estate taxes. The rest comes from intergovernmental grants, fees and fines, investment income and fund balance. 

Open Space: In his Budget Message, McClure notes has set aside $3 million for open space, something he has done every year. He believes this is one way that the county can slow down warehouse proliferation

Emergency stabilization fund: This is also known as the rainy-day fund, and County Council requires a minimum balance of 5% of the total expenditures expected over the course of the year. The county has set aside $8.1 million, or 5.6% of anticipated expenditures.  

Gracedale: No county funds will be needed to keep Gracedale operational. 

Employee costs: Northampton County has budgeted for 1,913 full and part-time employees, although the total number right now is closer to 1,700.  Career service (nonunion) workers are getting a step in their PayScale, which translates to a 4.5% raise. Union salaries have also increased in accordance with collective bargaining agreements with the county's 11 unions. Yet the total cost of salaries and benefits has decreased 1.4%. In 2024, $166.2 million was set aside for salaries and benefits. But McClure has set aside $163.9 million, over $2 million less in 2025. This might be because the county is asking employees to pay more for healthcare. The county contribution to healthcare and dental is projected to be $705,600 less this year than it was in 2024. 

There were major issues with three amendments proposed by Council members John Goffredo and John Brown. 

Goffredo proposed removing a little over $3.1 million in operating expenses across all divisions and P25 radio system. He clarified last night that he wanted to reduce operation expenses, but not salaries or benefits. Fiscal Director Steve Barron said that this would result in an unbalanced budget. Moreover, this change would require him, and not Council, to decide where these cuts are made. Goffredo and Council Solicitor Chris Spandoni countered that the budget would still be balanced and would give the administration the "discretion" to decide where to make cuts. 

Participating by phone, Council member Ron Heckman applauded Goffredo for making an effort, but said "you're not going to get anywhere if there isn't a cooperative attitude between the administration and Council." 

Goffredo's proposed amendment failed in a 5-4 vote. Voting yes were Goffredo, Brown, Lori Vargo Heffner and Tom Giovanni. Voting no were Ken Kraft, Kelly Keegan, Jeff Corpora, Jeff Warren and Ron Heckman. 

Brown's major amendment was the addition of $5 million to the county's "rainy day" fund. A Council ordinance concerning the rainy-day fund requires that between 5-15% in operating expenses be set aside. In conformity with that ordinance, McClure's proposed budget set aside 5.6%. This amendment does throw the budget out of balance, and Fiscal Director cited several examples of where the county could fall short, from money for raises to money for health care costs. Brown said it would be up to the administration to "rebalance the budget." 

Council member Heckman agreed with Barron's contention that he would be presented with what is in effect a Morton's fork, a choice between two equally unpleasant alternatives. 

The one big amendment that passed was the removal of $1 million for outside nurses at Gracedale to fund the P25 radio system. After basically accusing Fiscal Director Steve Barron of lacking transparency, Vargo Heffner gaveled Barron down when he attempted to defend himself and called for the vote even though the matter was not fully debated. 

The removal of $1 million for nursing services at Gracedale was approved by Goffredo, Brown, Vargo Heffner, Corpora and Giovanni. It was opposed by Ken Kraft, Kelly Keegan, Jeff Warren and Ron Heckman. 

The budget amendments collectively were adopted by a 6-3 vote. Voting Yes were Goffredo, Brown, Vargo Heffner, Corpora, Heckman and Giovanni. Voting No were Keegan, Kraft and Warren. The budget itself was adopted by a 7-2 vote, with only Kraft and Keegan dissenting. 

This is the seventh no-tax hike budget under Exec Lamont McClure. One of them actually included a tax cut. 

Updated 9:50 am to reflect that Warren votes Yes to the budget. 

McClure Tells NorCo Council That He Will Present New Bond Ordinance For Parking Deck and P25 Radio

At their November 7 meeting, Northampton County Council voted 5-4 to reject a $63.5 million bond for a new parking deck and 3-story office building at the courthouse campus, as well as a $14 million contingency for other projects that include a new roof at the jail and P-25 radio equipment, costing $6 million. Council President Lori Vargo Heffner and Council member Jeff Corpora both said they had no problem with building a new parking garage but suggested a brief delay to review details on options about building the garage but delaying the county office building. Council member Jeff Warren insisted on a vote then and there, and the bond was killed by Council members Vargo Heffner, Corpora, John Goffredo, John Brown and Tom Giovanni. Instead of getting a badly needed parking garage, the county got nothing.  

At last night's meeting of NorCo Council, Executive Lamont McClure stated that after discussions with Corpora, he has begun the process of introducing a bond that "is something short of what we originally proposed." He said the new bond would include the demolition and replacement of the parking deck at the courthouse complex, with the ability to add a county office building in the future, It would also include funding for the P25 radio system. 

This pretty much addresses the concerns Council had. 

Council Clerk and Solicitor Both Give NorCo Council Bad Advice

At its November 26 Budget Hearing, Northampton County Council considered seven different amendments, two of which are apparently unlawful. I explained why yesterday. One of the seven amendments was Council President Lori Vargo Heffner's attempt to divert $225,000 set aside for outside nursing at Gracedale for yet another pointless passenger rail study. Aside from Vargo Heffner herself, that amendment received no support. Council Clerk Alina Shafnisky solemnly instructed Council that amendments needed the support of all five Council members in order to move forward to the budget hearing. "If these budget amendments are not passed by motion at this meeting, they will not move forward for the adoption of the budget," she pronounced. And Council Solicitor Chris Spadoni chimed in as well. "They die tonight," he instructed.

They are both incorrect. 

Typically, what happens at the final budget meeting, which takes place tonight, is that Council votes separately on each budget amendment. Then they are all put together and voted on as a package.. If necessary, there's a recess so the Clerk can compute the changes and their effect on the final budget. Shafnisky obviously wants to have her figures ready to go, but the reality is that budget amendments can be proposed any time after the public hearing on the budget and up and until the budget is actually adopted. Yes, there needs to be a public hearing at which members of the public can be heard. 

Under our Home Rule Charter, the Budget is adopted by ordinance following at least one public hearing.. (Section 704(a)). It further provides that "After the public hearing and before adoption, the County Council shall have the power to amend the budget submitted by the County Executive." (Section 704 (b)). The only time constraints are that budget amendments be proposed after the public hearing but before final adoption.

I'm unclear whether there has actually been a public hearing on the budget ordinance. Assuming that has happened, only then may budget amendments be introduced. And under the Charter, they can be introduced up and until the budget itself is adopted. Nothing in the Charter requires that the only time they can be introduced is at the final budget hearing. That might make life easier for the Clerk, but it's not the law or even prior practice. I have often seen last-minute changes on the night of adoption. Bruce Haines from Hotel Bethlehem has made numerous last-minute appearances with his hand out. And Council has obliged him because Haines and any member of the public has the right to request changes. 

Amazingly, after both Shafnisky and Spadoni told Council that amendments needed five votes to push forward, they have submitted John Brown's amendment to add $5 million to the rainy-day fund on this evening's agenda. His proposed amendment received only four votes. As I previously explained, this will result in an unbalanced budget if it is adopted. 

Shafnisky and Spadoni both gave bad advice but ignored their own instructions to push an amendment that they have to know is unlawful.  

NorCo Council's Changes to Proposed Budget Appear to Be Unlawful

Last week, Northampton County Council proposed seven amendments to next years proposed spending plan. Several are designed to bypass the normal grant process and dole out hotel tax grants to political allies of Republican Council members in Bath Borough and at Columbia Fire Co., where Council member John Goffredo is a member. Those are unseemly and politically motivated, but at least they're legal. Unfortunately there are also two proposed changes that will violate the Home Rule Charter and run afoul of ordinances and contracts approved by Council. 

The first of these comes from Council member John Brown, who really should know better. He wants to restore $5 million to the county's "rainy day" fund. This was budgeted to cover two months of county expenses in accordance with both a previously enacted ordinance as well as government accounting standards. Brown introduced this amendment because he thinks more money should be set aside for possible unforeseen events. But there's a problem. Fiscal Director Steve Barron told Council that if they adopt this amendment, "the budget is out of balance."

The Home Rule Charter makes very clear that Council must adopt or approved a balanced budget. (Sec. 703 (b)). "There is a transfer out when we need that money to balance the budget," noted Barron. 

Council President Lori Vargo Heffner asserted that, if Council passes such an amendment, it is the Executive's job to somehow make it work. But McClure disagreed and said an unbalanced budget would be a nullity. 

This proposed change only received support from Council members Brown, Vargo-Heffner, Tom Giovanni and John Goffredo. Earlier that evening, Council Clerk Aline Shafnisky said that an amendment needed five votes to move forward, but some members of Council desire to present it anyway. 

The second proposed amendment comes from Council member John Goffredo, who was apparently miffed that McClure attacked Council for ignoring public safety when it rejected a bond that would have included funding for an improved radio system for first responders. He proposed to cut spending "across all divisions" by 2.5% and set that money aside for the radios. 

Goffredo's proposal is unlawful for several reasons. 

First, under the Home Rule Charter, Council has no authority "to delete or decrease any items required by law or for debt service or for estimated cash deficits." (Sec. 704(b)(3)). By imposing an across-the board spending cut of 2.5%, Council would violate the Charter's proscription against decreasing the amount set aside for debt service. 

Second, Council's across-the board spending cut of 2.5% would necessarily mean that monies budgeted for wage increases to union workers would be paid at lower amounts that guaranteed in union contracts that Council itself ratified. Corrections officers, Gracedale nurses, 911 operators and Human Services workers would be denied what the county promised to pay them in increased wages. 

Third, Council's across-the board spending cut of 2.5% would result in a reduction of payments to vendors who have valid contracts with the county that Council itself approved. 

Finally, Goffredo's amendment assumes that this money can be taken from county vacancies. But that assumes that there will be vacancies. If the county is able to fully man the Juvenile Justice Center, Gracedale or the jail, it will lack the resources to hire for positions that were budgeted and approved by County Council. Instead of having the money to pay for needed and budgeted manpower, the county would be forced to do without or borrow money to hire. 

This is a foolish amendment. It was obviously proposed to interfere with the efficient operation of the county in a political attempt to spite McClure. It was supported by Republican Council members Tom Giovanni, John Brown and John Goffredo as well as Democrats Jeff Corpora and Lori Vargo Heffner. They all like to accuse McClure of vindictive behavior, but this response would hurt the entire county, especially its employees. 

It is a very disappointing display from elected officials who are more interested in carrying on a war with the Exec than the best interests of the county. 

We'll see what happens Thursday night, when they take up the budget. 

McClure: Biosolids to Be Banned at All County-Owned Farms

 At the most recent meeting of NorCo's Energy and Environment Committee, Executive Lamont McClure announced that biosolids, often called sludge, is being banned on all county-owned farms. NorCo currently owns six farms totaling about 500 aces, which are leased to local farmers. McClure stated he wants these farms to be "models for best practices in conservation and sustainable agriculture." 

This ban is inapplicable to farms preserved with agricultural conservation easements. 

Worthy of the 8th or 9th Century

Here in the US, most of us speak English only and have little interest in other countries and cultures. Historically, we've been isolationists and have tended to view outsiders with suspicion if not fear. "Founding Father" John Adams signed into law the Alien and Sedition Act, which basically gave him the right to deport noncitizens he considered dangerous. Fortunately, that part of the law expired. "Founding Father" Thomas Jefferson said it was "worthy of the 8th or 9th century," But 1000 years later, in 1882, we adopted the Chinese Exclusion Act in reaction to xenophobia aimed at Chinese. Another law was aimed at excluding Chinese women. Our record of intolerance is no reason for pride. And now, we're gearing up for mass deportations. While the removal of violent criminals or national security threats is certainly warranted, I question whether we're just going to start rounding people up because they look or sound different. 

Now this is what a majority of American people want. Many of those who voted for Trump considered border security a top issue. It seems to me, however, that our attitude towards others are, as Jefferson said, ""worthy of the 8th or 9th century."

If Biden Pardoned Son Because "Politics Infected the Process," Shouldn't He Also Pardon Trump?

 In a Sunday shocker, President Joe Biden pardoned son Hunter for any "offenses against the United States which he has committed or may have committed or taken part in during the period from January 1, 2014 through December 1, 2024." This would include his convection for lying on an application to purchase a firearm, his guilt plea to tax charges and possible corrupt behavior in attempting to work deals with business counterparts in Ukraine and China. Biden issued this pardon despite a pledge he would not do so because "raw politics" infected the process, leading to a "miscarriage of justice." If that is so, and if he really is intent on bringing us all together, shouldn't he also pardon Donald Trump?

Now you could argue that such a pardon is unneeded because, once he takes office, Trump is immune. That immunity ends, however, once he steps down. 

Now don't get me wrong. There is no doubt in my mind that Trump most certainly instigated an attempted coup on January 6, 2020. I am also convinced that he actively obstructed investigators who were seeking confidential records. But he has already been tried in the court of popular opinion, and somehow managed to be the first GOP candidate in 20 years to win the popular vote. Many of his supporters are convinced that, just like Hunter Biden, Trump was the victim of "raw politics." I disagree with that sentiment but have to acknowledge that many voters feel that way. 

If Biden were truly concerned about what Republicans like to call lawfare, he'd pardon Trump. If he wanted to bring us together, he'd pardon Trump. He instead is looking out for a wayward son who attempted to use his father's name to make money. 

Who Is Running For NorCo Council's Five At-Large Seats?

Northampton County Council consists of nine members. Four of these represent specific geographic areas of the county. The remaining five are in what are known as at-large seats, meaning they are selected by the entire county. The five current at-large members are Council President Lori Vargo Heffner, VP Ron Heckman, John Brown, John Goffredo and Jeff Corpora. Their terms all expire at the end of next year. Who among these are planning to seek re-election?  And who else is running?

Of the current at-large members, I believe Ron Heckman may be planning to step aside when his term expires. Although he drives me nuts with perorations are nearly every topic, he perhaps more than anyone understands that county council is an independent body and has been willing to make that clear to Executive Lamont McClure on a number of occasions. He's his own man and has a deep understanding of county government since he has served both as an administrator and on Council. If he does step down, he will be missed. 

Lori Vargo Heffner is often the target of numerous anonymous attacks on this blog because, like Heckman, she has been an independent voice who has opposed many of McClure's proposals. She has also been willing to work with Republican Council members, even appointing some of them to chair different committees. She has stood up to the Executive, even though it may have cost her union support. Most of the arrows aimed at her are misplaced, but she has been her own worst enemy at times. Some of her votes and positions do appear to more obstructionist than well-meaning. It's unclear to me whether she plans to seek re-election. There were early rumors that she planned to primary McClure, but I have no idea what she is planning. I would support her re-election to county council, but not as Exec. 

Jeff Corpora was appointed by the court to replace Tara Zrinski after she was elected as Controller. Corpora was appointed by the court because Council was deadlocked over Zrinski's replacement. Corpora is even more quiet than Tom Giovanni, and I have no idea whether he plans to mount a campaign. 

Contrary to many of the comments posted here, I doubt John Brown plans to run against McClure. He is neither transparent nor accountable and is known for ignoring media inquiries. His secret plan to move the jail to Gracedale was exposed when he was Executive. Also, a tax increase was passed when he was Executive. So I doubt he'll run for Exec. But it's likely he will seek re-election to County Council because he has high name recognition. 

John Goffredo is probably the most vocally conservative member of Council. Philosophically, I disagree with most of his stands. He basically believes the less government, the better. I believe government exists to help people, and that it improves people's lives. Goffredo is a very well-known name in the northern tier, and I believe he would win easily if he decided to seek re-election. But he may be stepping down. This could be because he has two young children, or it could also be because he's going to run for Executive. 

So who's running? According to Lehigh Valley News, Nadeem Qayyum has announced. He's already lost two races. He was an unsuccessful candidate for Magisterial District Judge and then lost a race for Controller. He is either married or the life partner to divisive Easton City Council person Taiba Sultana, whose antics turned Easton City Council into a clown show for several months.

Other Democratic names I have heard include Patti Bruno, Leslie Altieri, Wind Gap Borough Council member Jason Boulette and union leader Paul Anthony. 

After November's red wave, I suspect there will be several GOP candidates. But thus far, I know of none.  

NorCo Council Proposes Funding Radio System: McClure Claims He Will Be Left With Unbalanced Budget

Last night, Northampton County Council met to consider seven amendments to the Executive's proposed budget for next year. They adopted six, some of which the administration contends violate the Home Rule Charter's requirement of a balanced budget. 

Before I get into them, let me tell identify the participants so I can refer to them by surname. 

The cast consisted of Council members Lori Vargo Heffner, Jeff Corpora, John Brown, John Goffredo, Kelly Keegan, Jeff Warren, Ron Heckman, Ken Kraft and Tom Giovanni. Executive Lamont McClure, Fiscal Affairs Director Steve Barron, EMS Director Todd Weaver and Community and Economic Development Director Tina Smith. Heckman was unable to attend in person for good reasons made known to County Council in advance. Warren had to leave after the third amendment to attend a parent-teacher conference for his children.  

Before Council got into the actual amendments, Barron reminded them that the Home Rule Charter makes clear that the budget must be balanced. Unlike the federal government, the county has no money trees. Ttal proposed spending may not exceed anticipated revenue. Council does have the power to amend, but it must leave intact any payments scheduled for debt service and it has no authority to modify the Executive's revenue estimates. If it wants to fund something, it has to find the money by making cuts elsewhere. 

1) DCED COVID response grants. Removal of $225,000 for a bi-county rail study by the Lehigh Valley Planning Comm'n. (LVPC) Proposed by Vargo Heffner. 

McClure called the amendment "misguided" and explained this money is intended for agency nursing at Gracedale. He added that LVPC is already sitting on $4 million of NorCo funds gathering interest.  Vargo Heffner proposed it because Lehigh County has set aside funds and wants a match from NorCo. They only would get the money if a rail study is actually done. County. 

Goffredo agreed with McClure, saying the money is sorely needed at Gracedale. Kraft would love to have passenger rail, but "we've been talking about a train forever."

This amendment died for lack of a second.. 

2) Take away $8,000 in hotel taxes for IronPigs and LV Public Telecommunications Corps to provide $8,000 for Bangor's 150th birthday celebration. Proposed by Giovanni. 

Bangor had asked for $20,000 for the birthday bash and general marketing and was awarded $15,000.  Kraft said he is opposed because all three entities applied for grants and were recommended for them.  Giovanni wants the money because the committee organizing it has a budget of $100,000.  

Supported by Corpora, Vargo Heffner, Brown, Goffredo and Tom Giovanni.. 

3) Remove $25,000 from gaming grants to Bath Borough Hall and Firehouse for the purchase of backup generators.  Proposed by Giovanni. 

Bath Borough did not apply for this project, noted Smith has concerns. Bath Fire Co did get $15,000 for mobile radios. Kraft said they should apply next year and get more money. Giovanni said there is no backup power. Goffredo agrees that the grant process is one way, but Council members hear from constituents with reasonable requests. There must be a cash match. 

Supported by Corpora, Vargo Heffner, Brown, Goffredo and Giovanni.. 

4) Remove $3,166,965 across all divisions to partially fund the P25 radio system.  Proposed by Goffredo. 

Goffredo stated the county typically budgets 120% of what is actually spent.  He added that a  P25 radio system is a "matter of life and death," but does not need a bond issue. 

McClure said he doubts there are six votes for this, and he will veto it. A 2.5% cut would require McClure to reduce the step increase for career service to zero. He said that county does not spend all that is budgeted because of vacancies. Barron later addeed that not all money is spent because it is encumbered. 

Weaver, EMS Director, said P25 was purchased from Bethlehem in 2019. To expand it, EMS secured grants for five sites. To continue the expansion, Weaver asked that it be included in a bond issue. Infrastructure must be in place before it can be tested. Vargo Heffner was irritated that the administration is now opposed to getting funding. "If you think it's funny, keep laughing, but I don't," she said to McClure. "You accused us of neglecting public safety."

McClure insists this amendment will result in an unbalanced budget and it also is cutting the court's budget and the DA's budget. It could lead to a lawsuit over the administration of justice.  Goffredo, said to McClure, "If we spend less than we project for, why not project a little less and then we'll have money for the radios?"

Supported by Corpora, Vargo Heffner, Brown, Goffredo and Giovanni.. 

5) Remove $10,000 from future table grants to give $10,000 to Columbia Fire Co for a tool upgrade special unit. They asked for $20,000 and got $10,000. Proposeed by Giovanni

Supported by Corpora, Vargo Heffner, Brown, Goffredo and  Giovanni..

6) Adding $5 million to financial stabilization "rainy day" fund. Proposed by Brown.

Barron stated this knocks the budget out of balance. McClure stated this would be a nullity and that the budget as he originally proposed it, would be the adopted budget. Vargo Heffner accused McClure of dramatics 

 Supported by Vargo Heffner, Brown, Goffredo and Tom Giovanni..

7) Removal of $775,000 from COVID grants to fund P25 radio project. Kraft asked if we could use COVID grants for P25. Barron stated that COVID money may be used for public safety. (Unsure who proposed this amendment)

Making a choice between agency nurses at Gracedale and P25.

Supported by Corpora, Vargo Heffner, Brown, Goffredo and Giovanni..

It appears to me that Goffredo's $3 million cut would violate the Charter because it would require cuts to funds that are already encumbered or needed for debt service. It is abundantly clear that Brown's amendment would result in an unbalanced budget. 

NorCo Ambulance Ass'n Advocates Expanded Radio Service For First Responders

At their November 7 meeting, Northampton County Council voted 5-4 to reject a $63.5 million bond that would be used for a new parking deck and office building at the courthouse complex. It would also finance several other projects, including a $6 million P-25 radio system for first responders. These replace analog radios with digital and have the capacity to transfer data as well as voice. 

Council members Lori Vargo Heffner and Jeff Corpora both said they had no problem with building a parking garage to replace an outdated and unsafe structure. But they wanted more details on options about building the garage but delaying the county office building. Council member Jeff Warren wanted a vote on the entire package, all or nothing. He got nothing. Democrats Corpora and Vargo Heffner joined Republicans John Brown, John Goffredo and Tom Giovanni in voting down the bond. 

Since that time, the Council members who voted No have been criticized for voting against public safety, especially with regard to the parking deck. But there's been no attempt to separate what a consensus of Council wants from the office building, the only controversial part of the bond proposal. 

At the November 21 meeting of NorCo Council, Executive Lamont McClure shared a letter he received from Daniel Gordon, President of the NorCo Ambulance Ass'n: 

"The NorCo Ambulance Ass'n would like to lend its voice of support for the effort to expand the County's Motorola Astro P25 advanced communications system. This strategic expansion will not only enhance radio coverage for emergency responders but will also ensure the adoption of cutting-edge communication technology necessary for the effective operations during emergencies. 

"The expanded P25 system will deliver secure wide area communication providing seamless interoperability among all county emergency service organizations. By replacing the current communication infrastructure, which is prone to interference, the new system will ensure reliable uninterrupted communication when it is needed most during critical incidents and emergencies. This project represents a pivotal advancement in public safety capabilities. The upgraded P25 system will significantly improve response times and operational efficiency, ultimately contributing to a safer environment for all county residents. 

"Additionally, we strongly support the continued funding of the Northampton County public safety grant program. The use of bond funds for this initiative will support public safety agencies across the county while simultaneously allowing general tax revenues to be directed to other essential services. In closing, we commend your efforts to fund the P25 system expansion through bond proceeds and would like to extend our sincere appreciation for the recent upgrades to the radio infrastructure in the southern region of the county. These investments demonstrate a steadfast commitment to enhancing public safety and ensuring that our emergency responders have the tools they need to protect and serve our communities effectively."

Participating by phone, Council member Ron Heckman questioned why the county was unable to use funds from its fund balance, but Finance Director Steve Barron stated that money was needed to balance the budget. 

Council member Goffredo suggested splitting the cost over two years, but McClure was uncertain whether that is possible. 

What McClure could do is introduce a new bind without the county office building until a majority of County Council supports it and the interest rates make it worth it.