In early October, Northampton County Exec Tara Zrinski proposed what amounts to a roughly 43.5% increase in property taxes for 2027, increasing the millage rate from 10.5 to about 15.6 mills. There had been numerous warnings before her announcement, so everyone knew a tax hike was coming. But no one expected it to be that high. It has been deeply unpopular with County Council, who were blindsided by the magnitude. It sparked an op-ed from Lamont McClure, Zrinski's predecessor as County Executive. It has also been unpopular with the general public. On Friday afternoon, at a press conference that attracted only three journalists, and that's only if you count me, Zrinski's remarks can be summed up with these three words - "I have listened." She's proposing revisions to her original proposal that will reduce the tax hike from 43.5% to 20.4%. Most of them mirror amendments proposed by Council members the previous day.
To be clear, aside from partisan Republicans like GOP Chair Glenn Geissinger, just about everyone agrees a tax hike is needed. The county grows no money trees in its numerous parks. It's absurd to suggest that it cut services like running a jail, answering 911 calls, administering court records or providing help to children and seniors in need. There is also no real dispute, even among hardcore Republicans like former Council members John Goffredo and John Brown, that the employees who provide these services are woefully underpaid. But there never was a need for a 43.5% tax hike.
Zrinski has no authority to submit an amendment to her own budget. She will have to rely on County Council to do so for her.
The week before Zrinski's announcement, three Council members sat down with Budget Administrator Brandon Dunstane and made clear that significant cuts were coming. They included (1) a reduction in retirement contributions from $15.2 million to around $5 million; (2) a reduction in the annual $3 million open space contribution to $1.5 million; (3) a cut in capital projects from $3.78 million to $1.925 million: (4) a cut in the Gracedale contribution that lowers funding set aside for agency nursing and eliminates payraises for a management team that has seen the nursing home's license downgraded from Regular to Provisional I ... to Provisional II ... to Provisional III; and (5) elimination of the operating budget for Continuum of Care.
Dunstane warned that any cuts below a 2.5 mill tax hike would mean that the county would have to lay off employees. Zrinski's revisions, however, would be lower.
Zrinski called her original proposal an "honest" budget and now is calling her revisions honest as well.
I think she should look up the word.
The biggest mistake Zrinski made was her failure to consult with County Council before making her original proposal. Traditionally, both the Administrator and Fiscal Director should be lobbying Council members to see what will fly and what will crash and burn. If State Rep. elect Jeff Warren is to be believed, that never happened.
This process has also been something of a shooting match between Zrinski and her predecessor McClure. She has repeatedly said that her administration has been putting out fires since the day she took office.
Although McClure was a cheap bastard and something of a control freak, he also accomplished a lot during his eight years as Executive. Many of the actions he took literally saved lives, which is something few county Execs can say.
In a lengthy Facebook post last night, McClure noted that his 1 mill tax cut put $40 million into the pockets of taxpayers instead of county coffers. He correctly observes that Zrinski was trying to claw all that money back in one budget." He predicts the ultimate increase will be closer to 1 mill.
I'm predicting - and I'm always wrong - 1.5 mills.
No one complained about the taxes in Northampton County. McClure was the benefactor of a John Brown tax increase that allowed McClure to go eight years without needing to raise taxes. Isn't it coincidental that he found a need to lower taxes in a year when he was up for re=election? Tell us about his leadership that put Gracedale in the mess it is in and the County Prison in the shape it is in, or how he "balanced his budgets on the backs of his employees" and how he neglected to finance his obligations to the County's Retirement Fund, or the fund that pays for the County Obligations to Retirees. There's a reason he only won six districts in a three County Congressional Race and I only touched on a few. To do to Gracedale what he did in eight years is abominable.
ReplyDeleteIt is correct that it is actually Rs who raised taxes by one mill, creating an excess of revenue. As McClure points out, the county also received $63 million in federal funds during te pandemic, and I agree no tax hike was needed then and McClure reduced taxes at that time, not so he could win an election against a deeply flawed candidate, but because there was a pandemic and that money was needed by people who were struggling. While I would have funded the retirement fund, there is no need to fund OPEB, and his decision not to fund it had no adverse effect bc the pension fund is still around 90%. I do agree that his many of his decisions at Gracedale and with employees were wrong. As I said, he is a cheap bastard and something of a control freak. He can also be a bit vindictive, as Lori Vargo Heffner can attest. I do think he balanced budgets on the backs of employees, though he would argue I'm wrong. He is by no means the "bad guy" that people describe. And I repeat my assertion that his actions saved lives - literally. I do think he should have proposed a tax hike in his final year, and Ron Heckman was right to propose it. I prefer small hikes so that people can be paid appropriately for the services delivered.
DeleteLamont also benefited from 2 massive cash infusions for "Covid Relief" from the feds during his terms. He used much of it to cover massive operating deficits at Gracedale.
DeleteLamont saved zero lives, hid for weeks when CoViD emerged, and failed at nearly every executive task - especially keeping Gracedale safe.. Having a lazy and irresponsible council didn't help either. But he was the boss and people died while he simply did everything the Wolf administration wanted, while Wolf was winning an award for being man of the year for the OHIO restaurant association. McClure never stood up to Wolf or distinguished himself in way other than the stunningly deadly 18064 zip code in his backyard.
DeleteElimination of the operating budget for Continuum of care at Gracedale?
ReplyDeleteLay off employees? Two assistant directors of nursing is not needed at Gracedale.
ReplyDeleteIf the ADON'S are doing their jobs they are key for the size home. Especially now with all the agency staff and open positions and provisional licenses. Ask them what they do. It should be a lot! If they aren't then replace them
DeleteLayoff 1 ADON, 1 housekeeping supervisor, 1 medical records administrator, the business office manager, duplicates in the business office, many housekeepers and laundry workers and TR. Don’t need all the extra people for 430 residents. Offer them dietary or other hands on direct care staff positions or lay them off.
DeleteCut spending Government is too liberal with our money has been for years.
ReplyDeleteCounty council needs to share the blame for this mess. Too much rubber stamping up to now!
ReplyDeleteThat she so quickly lowered her tax grab by half, the second the men yelled at her, indicates she has no frickin' idea about budgeting or math. What an idiotic disgrace. Any increase disproportionately harms the least among us. And she's throwing big numbers that effect peoples' budgets around like darts on a dart board. It's not a game you rude and uncouth gum-snapping moron.
ReplyDeleteAbolish Continuum of Care. This never should have been approved.
ReplyDeleteWhatever it is.
The 2 new positions are not needed. There are staff that already should be doing those tasks.
DeleteStill too much! Long time generations can't afford it and are leaving the area. This is opening the area to transplants that are wrecked their previous state that's why they move here.
ReplyDeleteUs vs. Them. Gotcha.
DeleteHow much of the funds for agency staff are going to be eliminated? You do know most of the deficiencies have happened due to lack of PROPER training for agency staff. And lack of holding agency staff accountable for ANYTHING.
ReplyDeleteTZ needs to figure out her job. She wanted it after all. And she also needs to stop acting like a victim of circumstance. Stop whining. Stop acting like a savior and then reneging for the people. You can't have it both ways.
ReplyDeleteTZ is clueless. Just another job hopping politico. Her staff saved her @ss as Controller. Who will save her @ass as Executive?. No one I hope. Anyone for a cupcake?
DeleteO’Hair if your “reporting” is accurate Dumbstain needs to go. The County budgets for way more employees than it ever hires in any given year. Even your hero Lamont did that. Nobody will need to be “laid off” even at your 1.5 mils increase.
ReplyDeleteTony Ianelli, President and CEO of the Lehigh Valley Chamber of Commerce published an excellent column in yesterday’s Morning Call. In it he quoted Teddy Roosevelt. Tony published the quote it in its original gender exclusive form which reflected the times in which it was said. Since it is relevant to today’s discussion, I will repeat it in a more appropriate gender form:
ReplyDeleteIt is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong woman stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the woman who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends herself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if she fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that her place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.
Joe Welsh
East Allen Township
Great quote.... but this is not a position where "she" should be learning on the job! Same for her position as Controller.
DeleteJoe, a healthy society needs both the courage of the man or woman in the arena as well as the courage and perspective of the person in the stands. As George Orwell said, “ "To see what is in front of one's nose needs a constant struggle." Many in government roles become inflated in their opinions of themselves and their own importance, thanks to their cheerleaders. My role is to make them aware of what is in front of their nose when they fail to see it, and incidentally, that takes courage, too.
DeleteWow Joe, that really doesn’t help
DeleteTeddy Roosevelt: "I'm gonna come up with a timeless statement on courage, that will be repeated for decades..."
DeleteJoe Welsh:"Let's see if I can clean this up a bit."
Joe, please don't edit Mark Twain...
Benie, I absolutely agree that anyone who puts their name behind their comments shows the courage of their convictions, whether we agree with the substance or not. The anonymous stuff is just noise.
Delete-- Joe Welsh
East Allen Township
OMG, go away and stop auditioning for the Council vacancy. Your bloviating is nauseating! Anyone with an ounce of commonsense knows she's in over her head.
DeleteFor crissake, she's a politician. Only murderers and rapists are held in lower regard. Touch grass and grow up.
DeleteTara would never stand up
Deletefor you, Joe, the way you are standing up for her. You should trust that but you may not because I’m anonymous.
We have the most incompetent Executive in history! She lacks basic Economics and the emotional intelligence for the job- this just proves her stint as Controller was a farce.
ReplyDeleteHer "stint as Controller" was salvaged because she had a competent KNOWLEDGABLE staff who did the dirty work.
DeleteMost incompetent Exec in County history was John Brown, who knew nothing about County operations...but he was run by people who were perfectly happy so long as taxes did not rise, and they knew nothing about County operations.
DeleteShe used the Controller's office as a de- facto campaign headquarters. Her staff did all the work, and she just read their reports, since she had no clue on what she was doing.
Delete1121 am. John brown did good things for gracedale regarding equipment purchases beds, mattresses, furniture and patient lifts in his last year. All were greatly needed. He listened and purchased. The issues were safety and quality of care with these purchases. So you cant say he did nothing
DeleteBrown was bad, but Tara is terrible.
Delete3 journalists were too many- her pathetic act as an Executive is over.
ReplyDeleteTo propose a 43% tax increase without consulting anyone and then come back 2 weeks later with another proposal cutting the tax increase in half, just proves how unserious this clown is. She needs to do the job she was elected to, and stop auditioning for her next gig.
ReplyDeleteIf everyone could step back for a second, the first obvious problem here is Gracedale. The county is literally spending millions each year to benefit a few hundred residents.
ReplyDeleteMaybe I could live with that if they had no alternative, but they do. Other counties have closed their county homes and those residents were absorbed by other nursing homes in those counties.
That doesn’t happen in NorCo because the private homes are happy to shift the cost of caring for those few hundred low-income residents to the county taxpayer. All NorCo is doing by allowing this to happen is subsidizing the profits of the private homes.
Why does NorCo keep Gracedale open? Because county politicians want to protect the union jobs there, and are worried that doing the right thing will hurt them politically. That’s it in a nutshell.
We’re not living in the 1800’s anymore. Gracedale needs to be closed. The industry has changed, and there are numerous private homes in the county that Gracedale residents can be spread across.
The cost is only going to get worse for county taxpayers. Not to mention the time and effort that is being spent by county government on a service that benefits very few.
Close Gracedale and focus on the functions of county government that actually still need to be handled by the county. That goes a long way towards closing the hole in the budget.
Our private nursing homes are, well . . . PRIVATE. Under one party (Democrat) control, I expect them to be legislated into something quite different.
DeleteFinally an analysis of Gracedale that makes sense.
DeleteToo long. Not reading it. Brevity is the soul of wit, blowhard.
DeleteSomeone explain how, in two weeks, a proposed budget was cut in half without much explanation. I would appreciate a
ReplyDeleteBreakout of what happened and how it happened?
What happened to Ds whining about affordability? I suggest we go back to Zrinski's original 43.5% increase. I can afford it. I've invested well and lived humbly. I want the vulnerable to pay up and learn a tough and expensive lesson. The rich aren't going to pay the increase. They're going to pass it on and make the poor pay for it.
ReplyDeleteShe needs to now see the political realty that her initial proposal was never going to be approved and also give County Council an opportunity to propose a few more spending cuts that she will accept to get the total package under a 20% increase. She will still take an initial political hit by doing this. By biting the billet in her first year in office, she however stands a chance of surviving the longer run backlash if she goes on in the remainder of her term to emphasize providing efficient and cost effective county services for both residents and businesses.
ReplyDeleteTara grow a set and keep your original budget.
ReplyDelete@11:34. Agree. I would have had more respect for her.
DeleteWhat everyone is fogetting about is the need for a re-assessment. This will cost the county somewhere between 8-12 million dollars and needs to be done sooner than later. You can keep kicking this can down the road but its eventually gonna have to happen. Perhaps whatever savings is found in this years budget will have to be spent in next years budget or the one after that. Keep in mind the cost for this will probably keep going up.
ReplyDeleteJust another tax increase done a different way. The effects on many would be huge and devastating
DeleteI think what TZ did was clever. By proposing a huge tax increase and then getting council a chance to make substantive cuts as well as her own cuts, she made a 20% tax increase look acceptable to the general public.
ReplyDeleteHammer meet nail. Tarable may be a lunatic but she’s not stupid.
DeleteTell that toseniors and renters and the least able to cover her cruel tax grab. She's hateful. Ask anyone who knows her well. She'll lie in court if she has to. Facts.
DeleteClever? She's an embarrassment!
DeleteCrazy stupid!
DeleteEvery time Zrinski opens her mouth, I cringe- its like listening to a teenager. We're in for a long 4 years.
DeleteYea, that really builds trust …
DeleteOh she’s clever all right lol.
DeleteBernie - Did you see Taras response on Facebook this morning? Lamont and Tara bickering like a divorced couple. lol
ReplyDeleteAs usual she wrote about 50 paragraphs my eyes started to glaze over lol
DeleteI did not see it. I looked for it on McClure's page and on the County of Northampton page, but do not see it. If she posted it on her personal page, I won't see it bc she and Lori Vargo Heffner both blocked me years ago when they were new to Council and were a little more sensitive.
DeleteAsk Tara at the next meeting how many county supervisors they were able to recruit to work for them with the increased salary. As her how many RN's are actually Gracedale staff in the entire building. Please get actual answers. Not oh let me get back to you.
ReplyDelete