Easton City Council member Taiba Sultana claimed at Wednesday night's meeting of Easton City Council that she's the only elected official in Easton who cares about the black and brown community. This no doubt came as a shock to City Council VP Kenny Brown, He grew up in the throes of poverty, first in Philly and then in Easton public housing. His brother Carl went down the dark side, committing numerous armed robberies. He was killed by Easton police, who informed young Ken that "we killed your n----r brother." I think it's safe to say Brown cares. He's spent a lifetime proving it. Sultana appears to be using the recent arrest of a well-known black activist to paint all other Easton officials, even those who are black, as racist.
Here's some background. On May 31, Easton activist Lance Wheeler was arrested by Wilson Borough police while in the midst of conducting a donation drive for the victims of a fire on Ferry Street. He allegedly threatened three students while driving a school van for the Wilson Area School District. I spoke with him afterwards, and he told me his arrest was politically retribution by DA Terry Houck (Lance backed Steve Baratta, Terry's opponent) and Easton Mayor Sal Panto (who has no authority to tell his own police department who to arrest, to say nothing of Wilson Borough police). Council member Taiba Sultana was with Wheeler and filmed his arrest, focusing on Easton police officers. "I am outraged," she writes. "This is crazy," she says, as others use vulgar language and claim incorrectly that Wheeler was arrested for helping the community. Wheeler himself is shouting obscenities at DA Terry Houck as he is led away.
I learned from Wheeler himself that he rejected pleas from Wilson police to come in and take care of the arrest. He knew they were coming. He also insisted on being cuffed. After all, it makes the video that much more dramatic. At the time that Sultana was expressing her outrage, she was apparently unaware that what happened was essentially a PR stunt.
Easton police were present for Wheeler's arrest. This is standard protocol when one jurisdiction comes into another to make an arrest. They had nothing to do with the arrest or the underlying charges. Wilson Borough police wanted this wrapped up quickly. Wheeler is a constable and owns multiple firearms. Though it's highly unlikely, they have to consider the possibility of a standoff had they given a person accused of assault and terroristic threats the time to get angry at being charged.
Easton police were upset by Sultana's video. It certainly implies they acted arbitrarily, and they registered their concerns with Easton Mayor Sal Panto and Council member Kenny Brown. They in turn relayed those concerns to Sultana at a committee meeting earlier this month. Unfortunately, there is no video, but the Express Times reported that Sultana became defensive.
That should have been the end of it. Sultana was "outraged" to see someone arrested in the midst of collecting donations. She thinks police should have waited until he was finished for the day. Gee, what if he had been accused of rape or murder? Would she still be "outraged"? Once she learned that Wheeler basically gave Wilson Borough police no choice and insisted on being cuffed, and that Easton police played no role in what had happened, a "Never mind!" was far more appropriate than "I am outraged." Instead of toning down the temperatures a bit, an angry Sultana doubled down at Easton City Council on Wednesday night. (You can see the video here). Here are excerpts:
Sultana: "I have every single right to express how I feel. ... I am a minority, a woman, an immigrant, a Muslim, and I want every race of human being who live in the City of Easton to be treated equally, not marginalized and targeted. ... Any woman who stands behind this podium and asks questions has been intimidated by the male elected officials and it's on record. ... I refuse to accept the status quo and will not allow a group of men to intimidate a woman of color."
...
"They think the black and brown community is criminal and dangerous ... ."
Panto: "I don't understand what you're upset about because what the police chief and I were looking for was an apology. Whether you want to give our Easton police an apology or not, that's up to you. I never wanted to silence your voice. All I was pointing out was that our police department was there because the warrant served by the Wilson Borough Police and the DA's office was there [in Easton]. Mr. Wheeler was given the chance, a phone call, to turn himself in; he chose not to. He was given a chance of not being handcuffed; he chose not to. Our police were there solely because the warrant was being served in the City of Easton. ... You put them on the video, not the Wilson police. "
Brown: "As an African American person, I cannot allow myself to look on just one side of the fence. ... Whenever you're in the position that we're in, we've got to be very careful about the things that we do, and the things we say in public because, more times than not, that information that we're disseminating outward can be looked upon in a bad way. And no, I don't think Council woman meant to do it in a bad way, but I believe we need to take a step back and let the process work. That's what I was trying to say."
Sultana went on to insist that she receive a public apology from Panto. "You all ganged up on me," she complained. "You ganged up on 63 police officers," responded Panto. Brown declinedto apologize, saying that he was just trying to share what he's learned after 36 years of public service. He noted Sultana's Facebook post resulted in people accusing him and Panto of ordering Wheeler's arrest.
Brown: "You don't know my story. You don't know where I came from. You don't know I lived in the worst project in the United States of America, in North Philadelphia. You don't know that I was drawn into a gang and got transferred out of Philadelphia to come up here. You don't know my story. You only know where you came in at. I fight hard for this city. I fight hard to represent my family. my friends and my community because of one thing - I made a solemn promise to my brother on his death bed that I would never, ever, ever give up and that I would fight to change our name to the good. I think I've done that. I carry that on my sleeve and I would never allow anyone to tell me I don't fight for anyone. I don't care if you're white, black, yellow. It has nothing to do with it."
Ironically, the meeting ended when a black woman named Jackie - one of the very people Sultana claims to champion - told Sultana that she was at the courthouse on the day Wheeler was arrested and learned there was a warrant for him. She advised Wheeler of the warrant, and she claims he told her he wanted to be arrested.