About a year ago, warehouses were the bogeymen. Politicians loved to rail against them, and we all lapped it up as we continued ordering toilet paper through Amazon. But there's now an evil more evil monster lurking around every corner - the Data Center. Never mind that they've been with us for decades. Never mind that they are a critical national infrastructure to support both our economy and yes, our national security. They're bad, I tell you. 1,000,000 Facebook groups can't be wrong.
On Friday night, I could have stayed home to watch President Donald Trump and our betters in the Washingtom press corps insult each other. I opted instead to travel to Angle country, where Upper Mount Bethel Tp was hosting a hastily called "special" meeting in an effort to put the brakes on yet another potential and very evil data center located on Pektor property by both the river and a power plant.
I arrived a little late, so I missed the remarks made by His Eminence, the Right Reverend Ron Angle. But that's ok. Though Supervisors have limited Angle to three minutes, he manages to inject himself after nearly every speaker anyway, So I got the drift. He thinks a lot of the kneejerk opposition to data centers is misguided. But he's wrong. They're evil, I tell you, the stuff of nightmares and science fiction movies where the noise they emit are really some sort of radio frequenct that turns us into pods.
I pulled into the parking lot of what is actually the public works garage because the second largest municipality in the goddamn state of Pennsylvania is unable to afford a frickin' municipal building. And that's pretty much because the people who live there - at least the ones with money - don't want anything that could actually help people who are working two or three jobs to make ends meet. The ruling class has decided that data centers are bad, and they know best. A year ago, they thought they were great, much preferable to an evil warehouse, but that was then.
Before I walked into the garage, I looked over the packed parking lot. It was full of big-ass SUVs and those massive trucks with V-8 engines. Not an ebike in sight. These folks are very environmentally conscious, except when it comes to themselves.
The reason for the rushed meeting was because the evil data center was just far too willing to work with the township. Supervisor David Friedman, who has previously botched up several negotiating sessions with Tam Pektor, was again spearheading the back-room meetings with Talen Energy. Talen Energy had offered a community benefits agreement of $25 million. Friedman reportedly said, "Make it $50 million and we have a deal," thinking this would be enough to send Talen away with its tail between its legs. Instead, after telephone calls with several Tallen execs, their ambassador came back and agreed.
What little is left of Friedman's head must have exploded. He was sure he had scared them off, but instead, they agreed. now, Friedman would have to break his word again, which obviously doesn't mean much to him as he also once promised to resign and then refused to keep his word. Friedman huddled with John "Voice of (some of) the People" Bermingham and came up with a plan that would scare away that evil data center for good. They decided to propose an amendment to the zoning ordinance that would impose all kinds of conditions on when and where they could be placed.
Good idea, but bad timing. Very bad timing. The evil data center, which I've told you is very bad, filed what is known as a "validity objection." In layman's terms, that is a giant FU to the township. It means that Talen can build a data center wherever the hell it wants and there's not a damn thing the township can do about it. It means that instead of a $50 million community benefits agreement, the township gets zero.
Great job, guys.
But there was nevertheless a procession of NIMBY speakers who basically are unreservedly opposed to data centers no matter what the benefits might be. They're bad, I tell you.
One heavy fellow wearing a "Jesus is King" T-shirt and who may have been thinking that Jesus is Burger King, claimed they are "out of control" and "poisoning the water supply." I've got news for Burger King. The people who live in Upper Mount Bethel are already poisoning our water supply with their own shit. Water tests done along the creeks on 611 show unusually high amounts of chemicals that come from residents' refusal to actually build a proper sewer.
These are the same people who incidentally complain about sludge.
Now I don't want to leave you with the impression that everyone in Upper Mount Bethel hates data centers. There were a few who said we should at least have an open mind and take a tour or two.
But when I hear these phonies raise environmental concerns, I have to laugh. Though they are the new bogeyman, consider these facts: You could give up a lifetime of reliance on data centers and AI, and the amount of energy saved would be negligible compared to canceling just one trans-Atlantic flight or switching to a hybrid car; A request to ChatGPT consumes as much energy as one second of a clothes dryer; our 14,000 golf courses consume 550 billion gallons of water a year; we use 3 trillion gallons of water a year just to water our lawns.
But don't let facts get in the way. Data centers are very bad,
McClure/Zirinski fueled this hate by going after pector.
ReplyDeleteNo worries- Pektor knows how to take care of UMBT Supervisors & their kids...
DeleteDid you ever notice Bernie is always on the side of the People except when very rich “friends” of his like Angle or Hyman have a different point of view ?
ReplyDeleteAnyone who is on the side of the people would support a data center that is properly regulated and offers $50 million in community benefits in an area where people are starving for jobs. The NIMBYs who oppose this already have theirs and have opposed every attempt to do something up there while their own shit contaminates the groundwater and streams.
DeleteAnyone on the side of the people would oppose the use a $29 million tax break for luxury apartments in Wilson, especially when the project could be built without that money. The people who support are elitists who have no regard for the burden they place on taxpayers while they recruit NJ and NYC transplants. This was opposed by Nat Hyman, true. It was also opposed by DSA and anyone with a brain.
If electricity was invented today the bib overalled hicks in umbt would vote against it.
ReplyDeleteFarmland uses exponentially more water per acre than any data center. It's not even close.
ReplyDeleteYou're probably referring to farming in the midwest or California where large scale irrigation is needed. In the Lehigh Valley regular irrigation is pretty rare. We have (had?) great soils and a good amount of rainfall. If you're going to count rain falling on a cornfield as it "using" that water then maybe you're right. But at that rate a forest "uses" even more water. Guess we should chop down the forests for data centers to save the fish.
DeleteEvery NIMBY who opposes data centers must sign a pledge and uphold it: no more amazon, streaming movies/TV, anything really online, nada. Back to the 80s with you. If you don't want data centers then you MUST stop contributing to their necessity. The AI bogeyman is hilarious, data centers do WAY more than house AI computer farms. And when water is used to "cool" data centers it returns to the earth, gets filtered, and rises back to the top. People act like water used to cool servers is then shipped to Mars. It's the same hysteria that said if we don't limit toilets to a per-flush amount of water that we would run out of water. The Earth just doesn't work that way.
ReplyDeleteReally, because we use ALL of those things now and there isn't data centers there. Try again 🙄
DeleteWell, well, well, it looks like the puppet master of the County is trying to groom his little puppets into having better attitudes about data centers. How obvious! Bernie, I hope that you get to live next to a data center that has loud incessant humming and it ruins all the things that you might enjoy during your bike rides, like clean water and clean air. And I hope there's dead smelling fish along your bike route. You deserve that and so much more.
ReplyDeleteThey may have to build a mini-nuclear reactor there to power it. I wonder if Angle will let them spread the waste on his fields like he does sludge.
ReplyDeleteWastewater from data centers does not "poison" aquafers. Fertilizer from farming poisons aquifers.
ReplyDeleteyou are 100% right
DeleteLuddite (noun)
ReplyDeleteLuddites (plural noun)
derogatory
a person opposed to new technology or ways of working:
"a small-minded Luddite resisting progress"" I'm not a Luddite, after all I work with the internet for my job"
Please take some time to research the noise pollution that a data center will produce, both audible and low frequency. There are ways to mitigate this, the townships should put very strict requirements on sound limits for the data centers.
ReplyDeleteI'm curious where you are getting your numbers. Data centers are currently consuming 4% of energy in the US and predicted to use 9% by 2035.
ReplyDeleteThe public utility commission has expressed concerns about energy usage and I know my electric bills are going through the roof.
Hyper scale data centers consume as much power as at least 50,000 houses.
State and municipal governments are trying to create laws and ordinances to limit the impact to residents, but right now most places are not protected and Northampton county residents will be footing the bill for these corporate profits on data centers.
Ann Flood is a BIG proponent of data centers. They are going to happen so don’t forget to call Ann’s office and thank her.
ReplyDeleteI'm voting for Jared Biting. Flood is as much of a shill as Bernie.
DeleteFriendly clarification: State Reps don't vote on individual data center developments.
DeleteZoning, site permits, and land-use decisions fall under local municipal and county jurisdiction (City Council, County Board, Zoning Board). State lawmakers pass general legislation and grid/tax rules, but local officials decide what actually gets built in the community.
Also find it funny that Kelly Keegan posted 1 minute after this comment! I get the feeling Kelly not a fan of Ann!
I do love a good cat right though! !!
No amount of money a developer can hand a township or municipality is worth the long-term cost to a community. Some things simply cannot be bought.
ReplyDeleteData centers can bring persistent noise, enormous energy demands, significant water consumption, thermal impacts, and increased air pollution associated with the electricity needed to power them. While developers may point to mitigation measures, those don't eliminate the fundamental tradeoff: the environmental footprint remains, and the community lives with the consequences long after the checks have been deposited.
When elected officials or residents choose developer dollars over protecting the health, environment, and quality of life of their own community, they're making a statement about what they value most. Clean air, clean water, peaceful neighborhoods, and responsible stewardship should never be treated as commodities to be traded away. Once they're compromised, no payment can truly restore what was lost.
It is our Pennsylvania constitutional rights state citizens have a right to clean air, pure water, and the preservation of natural, scenic, historic, and aesthetic environmental values, declaring public natural resources as common property for present and future generations. It mandates that the Commonwealth, acting as trustee, must conserve and maintain these resources. Figures you would support such an atrocity.
Kelly, stick to being a mediocre school nurse.
DeleteChina is behind all of the anti-data center social media groups.
ReplyDeleteIt is an acute national security issue.
So it’s that simple? It must be nice to believe in simple answers.
DeleteThe truth is more complicated, perhaps too complicated for you.
Yes, 12:44, it is simple. You are correct in that manipulating social media is only one tactic to support the strategy.
DeleteCouple the exponentially increasing power of each LLM along with the other models such as the one involved in the Facehugger hack, and it should become clear why these data processing centers are critical.
County Council needs to repeal the Pektor Tax Giveawy today. The good people of UMBT need to come to Easton and demand that the UMBT tax break for data centers be repealed !
ReplyDeleteit is ending in a few months, why bother. Pecker will never build it and he is already being bailed out again because he is insolvent
ReplyDeleteBernie, you and Kel-Kel Keegan have an interesting relationship.
ReplyDeleteShould we be expecting “save the date” notices soon?