Local Government TV

Wednesday, August 03, 2022

Bethlehem City Council Chided Over Backyard Chicken Obsession

Bethlehem City Council had a loaded agenda last night. There were never-ending LERTAs, zoning changes, the proposed demolition of the Banana Factory for a cultural center to backyard chickens. There were plenty of speakers, too. Most were anxious to weigh in on a new cultural center proposed by Artsquest. There were a several backyard chicken supporters, but the big draw was Artsquest's desire to tear down the banana factory, which had previously been nixed by the South Side Historic Conservation Commission. Now Musikfest, which is put on by Artsquest, is scheduled to start on Thursday.  It's a busy time for Kassie Hilgert and her numerous employees and volunteers. Yet she and many of them had to sit through a nearly four meeting before the subject was broached. 

Mayor Willie Reynolds, who had previously told Council how busy the City was in getting ready for Musikfest, rebuked City Council for making Artsquest officials wait at their busiest time of the year. He suggested that, out of courtesy, the matter should have been heard before the City's other business.

When they did finally get to it, City Council agreed with the proposed demolition and new cultural center by a 5-2 vote. Council members Michael Colon, Paige Van Wirt, Grace Crampsie Smith, Hillary Kwiatek and Kiera Wilhelm sided with Artsquest, though they really, really, really, really respect the Historic Conservation Commission and love history. Council members Rachel Leon and Wandalyn Enix sided with the Historic Conservation Commission, though they really, really, really, really love the arts and Arstsquest. 

All too often, I see historic conservation commissions used to bludgeon homeowners with page after page of ridiculous rules and regulations that have little to do with history but a lot to do with making neighborhoods exclusive. Here, it was being used as a sledgehammer to prevent a nonprofit organization which has done everything it can to preserve much of the rusting hulks once known as the Steel Stacks. 

Historic preservation is great for old churches and libraries, but a banana factory? Give me a break.

Dr. Lee Reilly, a physician who dabbles with art, told Council that "[h]umans have a basic need to be creative," and thinks the proposed cultural center will ignite artistic sparks in children for decades to come. 

Wait a minute, what about those damn chickens? 

Well, civil rights leader Esther Lee, church hat and all, addressed City Council about what certainly seemed like misplaced priorities. She said she'd like to see that much enthusiasm for the homeless.  

By the way, City Council decided to delay its vote for two weeks. Council member Paige Van Wirt, who had assured mayor Willie Reynolds just two weeks ago that she had all the details, apparently missed a few. Council President Michael Colon had to introduce a series of amendments, which must be advertised before a vote. So backyard chickens will have to wait two weeks, where another 100 people can come again. 

How does Mayor Reynolds feel about all this, asked President Michael Colon. 

"This is your ordinance, not ours," snapped Reynolds. He went on to note that the City has a lot of serious problems. "There are a lot of things on fire right now. On a 1 to 10 level, we're an 11." He went on to note that  there are 40 vacancies at City Hall, but workers who are left have been besieged with calls from people seeking chicken permits. He said that some of them even want "dreamer" permits for chickens who came to Bethlehem illegally, through no fault of their own, when they were little chickadees. His health director is dealing with monkeypox, Covid and other public health issues, but now has to deal with chickens.  

Call me cRaZy, but I'm beginning to think Hizzoner will veto chickens. 

44 comments:

  1. Shooting on Main Street apartment, illegal motor vehicle gangs flying through the streets and kids in bicycle packs blocking traffic. Absentee landlords letting properties go to crap.

    Yeah, Bethlehem is doing great. What we really need are chickens that will be unkempt and ruinous to Neiborhood's. If these carpetbaggers had any knowledge of the past, they would know Bethlehem did that and it weas a disaster.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Letting the dynasty boys, donchez and willie take over the city has been and will continue to be a debacle. Bethlehem voters, you earned this. glad I'm not there anymore.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Don’t worry willie is not busy answering phone calls

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm all for the chickens, fresh eggs, chicken pot pie for the old hens, and maybe even Saturday night rooster martial arts. Who needs music fest.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Chicken pot pie. Three of my favorite things!

      Delete
  5. Why are there 40 vacancies? Were employees fired for refusing to take a vaccine that didn't work? Remember when the "health care is a fundamental human right" crowd wanted shot refusers denied basic medical treatment? Is this what happened in Bethlehem? I'll check back for an answer. I must check on my 4x "vaxxed" neighbor who now has CoVid for the second time. Poor bastard damn near died last November. But he's still masking like a demon!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am gonna go ahead assume it is more of a morale issue. Mayor Reynolds is correct when he says city hall is at an '11' right now. As well as many other departments.

      Delete
    2. It most definitely is morale. When employees see people in administrative positions who aren’t qualified for their jobs, who mysteriously are MIA for “45 days”, who treat their subordinates like trash, yet the hard-working union level employees get targeted and terminated for unjust reasons… yeah, morale sinks pretty low.

      Delete
    3. Mr Reynolds will have some cleaning up to do. Kind of like left over trash just laying around.

      Delete
    4. Mr Reynolds brought the trash in.

      Delete
  6. Good morning! By chance, Bernie, do you or any of your readers know why Bethlehem stopped allowing backyard chickens in the first place? It seems to me, the discontinuing of the practice indicates there were problems. I am no fan of Willie Reynolds, but I think he is making a great deal of sense right now. As for ArtsQuest, too darn bad Kassie Hilgert and company had to wait their turn. They are no more important than any other person who wished to speak.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Empty nester Amy Zanelli is super pumped - she can never have enough chicks!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. What the cluck? Backyard chickens in a congested city? Sure. Bring on the disease, smell and noise. Welcome fox, coyotes, raccoons and other predators to roam city streets in search of chicken dinners. An eggscellent idea!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Cry me a freggin river that the greedy fest staff had to wait their turn. People's lives are upset/disrupted for 11 days straight.

    ReplyDelete
  10. if you want chickens get chickens there really isnt much they do about it fuck the ordinance hire some firefighters....put your political knowledge to good use ohhh! wait there isnt a smart one in the bunch..LOL

    ReplyDelete
  11. " Bernie, do you or any of your readers know why Bethlehem stopped allowing backyard chickens in the first place? It seems to me, the discontinuing of the practice indicates there were problems"

    Yes, they were banned bc of rooster fights. The current bill continues the ban on roosters.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Sexual discrimination at its worst, no roosters, it must be because of the women on the board. Roosters are necessary for the propagation of chickens, and who is going to go out and search for roosters.
    I don't live in beth or allentown, but if I did, I would play a recording of roosters, pigs, and cows every morning at 6Am.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I started out tending to support the idea as a pilot project. But it disturbs me that we've only heard from enthusiasts and not so much from city officials at a committee hearing that was requested by the Mayor and denied by Van Wirt, who claimed to "have all the details." It could be that Colon's amendments are an attempt to address those concerns. The Mayor indicated that city staffers are very opposed, and I really want to hear from them.

    I am also disturbed by comments that some readers left in my first post, noting that the infusion of chickens would attract predators. They are supposed to be in enclosed areas, but I doubt that will be the case for some or at all times. I'd hate to see small children attacked by coyotes looking for chickens. Is that a possibility? I don't know but would think that subject should be discussed. I also think this will be another bone of contention between neighbors in densely populated areas. If people complain over loud cars and parking spots, they will complain about chickens.

    I think the ordinance should require not only the approval of the homeowner, but the approval of all immediately adjoining homeowners.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is not a possibility. We don’t have coyotes in the city, so they certainly won’t magically appear because chickens exist. Take a look at Emmaus. They allow chickens, they have a smaller city but they have no predator issues. Filth brings rats, not chickens. Of course we already have raccoons and opossums, they only come out at night, they may look to get into a coop and have a feast but this really only affects the chicken owner…. And you learn pretty fast from one mishap.

      I appreciate they want to hear from city workers, but why not hear from experienced chicken owners instead?

      Another thought, if there were so many phone calls of people in opposition, than where were they at any of the meetings. Lord knows people of this city like to come out and complain.

      Lastly I’m rather disappointed with the obvious tantrum Willie is throwing as a grown man. I and thought a lot more of him. City hall lacking employees is really his problem, maybe pay more? They’ve pushed if off for years saying they’re too busy or other things are more important, but fresh food is important. To chide city council for not allowing musikfest to go first was completely unacceptable and if he was there the whole meeting, which he wasn’t… he’d have noticed that the other issues were very short and it made sense to get them done first. Is it that money comes first for him? What exactly was his reasoning. I really hope he can compose himself better and focus on what leadership means.

      Delete
    2. One more thing, if adjoining homeowners need to approve chickens maybe they should approve dogs as well since they have to deal with barking and smell.

      Delete
  14. I do like the suggestion you made, Bernie, that immediate neighbors should have to sign off on something that may directly impact their quality of life. I have neighbors who appear to be chicken-ready, but I would veto only because they clutter their yard with debris and I am not confident, by what I have seen, that they would be responsible “farmers.” I also think the City needs to take a few steps back and really determine need vs. want. Sometimes — and I emphasize sometimes — the government must protect us from ourselves.

    ReplyDelete
  15. The cock ban is sexist and may be hard on some. For cock meetings lasting more than four hours, seek emergency treatment right away.

    ReplyDelete
  16. It will be interesting to see how this is implemented. Will Willie direct that it not be implemented by his administration? That would set up an interesting legal dilemma. Will Council, or some chicken lover, bring a mandamus action?

    What is the added cost to the taxpayers for this chicken program? I assume the permit fee will not cover the entire cost to administer the program. Who will review the chicken coop designs? Do they need building permits? Or shed permits? Will there need to be setbacks, or variances for these coops? Seems like some valuable time in code enforcement and permits may be wasted.

    I think Willie was correct to want a committee meeting on this issue. I would not be surprised if there is a veto, depending on the council vote. Or if Willie decides to let it become law without his signature.


    ReplyDelete
  17. “A lot of things on fire”? Or a lot of people getting fired? 40 vacancies? Or 40 anticipated vacancies because the HR Director is on her high horse again digging to find things wrong so she can terminate those she doesn’t care for? This City is a mess and an embarrassment. Start at the top fixing problems and the results will trickle down.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And yet another major investigation is an ongoing issue. The hammer shall strike soon! Mr Reynolds walked into a hornets nest on his first day as Mayor. A bee keeper can only keep the nest intact for so long.

      Delete
  18. Will the chickens have free range of an enclosed back yard? What is a fence is only 4 feet high? They can potentially leap up and over that. What if a neighbor has a dog in their enclosed back yard? The pooch will bark nonstop with chickens next door. Hawks can swoop down on them. Dried chicken guano can blow up in the air and be breathed in by neighbors. This is a bird-brain proposal!

    ReplyDelete
  19. Bern over there in bedlum they just don't have a cock in the fight.

    ReplyDelete
  20. "That is not a possibility. We don’t have coyotes in the city, so they certainly won’t magically appear because chickens exist"

    Hate to break it to you, there are coyotes on south mountain and out near camel's hump. There are also fisher cats and bob cats near or in Bethlehem.

    Also, the City Council spent an hour talking about LERTA. It was a four hour meeting, and council spent 20 minutes saying how they support the HCC but were voting against them. The Arts Quest matter should have been moved out of courtesy to the people who came to the meeting.

    ReplyDelete
  21. We are all up in arms in the modern city of Bethlehem when we forget that it was less then 100 years ago when there were pigs, goats, and cows in many parts of the current Bethlehem. My how things change and then come full circle.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Bernie 9:49 you mention coyotes as predators. But we already have foxes in and around most of the town. They are bigger predators to chickens then Coyotes. Although coyotes are growling in abundance in the area there are are far more foxes.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Reynolds arrogant comment to Council about making Artsquest supporters wait for its rightful turn at the end of the agenda was immature political grandstanding. I give credit to Colon for ignoring him.

    Reynolds wants to control Council like he allowed Donchez to do while he was Council President. He was a lapdog for whatever Donchez administration wanted. I see this Council pushing back as they should to his antics as evidenced by the LERTA vote last night.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 🙌 you hit the nail on the head. Leave it to a majority of women to push back.

      Delete
  24. "Reynolds arrogant comment to Council about making Artsquest supporters wait for its rightful turn at the end of the agenda was immature political grandstanding. I give credit to Colon for ignoring him."

    Reynolds was absolutely right. This is their busiest time of the year, and it was a slap across their faces to make them wait and delay their Musikfest planning and execution. I have seen issues moved up on an agenda when people need to be somewhere. Colon probably never thought about it, but he had an unforced error.

    ReplyDelete
  25. What will be the fan favorite at musikfest this year? The Hokey Pokie or the Chicken Dance?

    ReplyDelete
  26. I never saw Reynolds move items on an agenda because people were waiting for their item to be voted upon.

    It was a cheap political stunt by the mayor because he was pissed off about the LERTA vote that had just taken place & took this cheap shot to embarrass them. Council had just ignored his appeal against raising the fee for affordable housing buyout against his favorite developer buddies.

    Then they proceeded with the chicken ordinance against his wishes to squash it so he went 0-2 & threw his bat like a spoiled kid that didn’t get his way.

    ReplyDelete
  27. This is what happens when you let crazy-ass liberals run a city. Chickens first, roads second. The city has a lot of problems, and other than CrAzY ass Zanelli, I have never heard of someone complaining about the lack of chickens in Bethlehem.

    The roads are horrible, code enforcement is lacking, and it takes forever to get a permit. These are the issues City Council should be focusing on.

    ReplyDelete
  28. @10:22. Just think if we dug a ditch across roads every couple hundred feet it would solve so many problems. Speeding would decrease, accidents would decrease, trucks traveling those roads would decrease. We would have to spend less on road maintenance. Less road crew employees, and taxes could go down.

    Oh yeah what a fantasy this would never happen the politicians would have less money to steal from everyone under the $3 dollars in 10 arrangement they are currently grifting. Tax you $10 for roads. grift $6 into other areas and others pockets, put $1 in their own pocket and put 3 toward the roads.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Code enforcement is either looking the other way or non existent as there is an illegal rather large shed being built directly under power lines and other utilities on Linden St directly across from Azar Market. Very dangerous situation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Because there’s an unqualified director running the show who’s too busy getting high to effectively run that department.

      Delete
  30. "Anonymous Anonymous said...
    Mr Reynolds brought the trash in."

    He did not bring in Karner, the HR Director, Evans, Evans, or Heller. Those are the biggest problems in the City. He should have cleaned house with this cabinet, and brought in all new people.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One can assume that Mayor Reynolds' eyes and ears are now more than used to seeing and hearing what really goes on in the shitty.

      Delete
  31. From the original post:

    "Mayor Willie Reynolds, who had previously told Council how busy the City was in getting ready for Musikfest, rebuked City Council for making Artsquest officials wait at their busiest time of the year. He suggested that, out of courtesy, the matter should have been heard before the City's other business."


    I would point out to Mayor Reynolds (and anyone else who was miffed about Artsquest officials having to wait) that if Artsquest is too busy to wait their turn, the city or Artsquest could have requested the matter be tabled until after Musikfest is over.

    Artsquest might believe they own the city and the rest of us our peasants, but they can wait their turn like everyone else.

    The complaint about waiting was likely a tactic to garner a quick review and vote from Council.

    ReplyDelete
  32. This blog about chicken makes me think of The old proverb of which came first:


    Which came first lying sacks of crap or politicians. Do you have to be a proven liar to be a politician or do you get trained to lie without remorse once you become a politician.

    Hmmm

    ReplyDelete

You own views are appreciated, especially if they differ from mine. But remember, commenting is a privilege, not a right. I will delete personal attacks or off-topic remarks at my discretion. Comments that play into the tribalism that has consumed this nation will be declined. So will comments alleging voter fraud unless backed up by concrete evidence. If you attack someone personally, I expect you to identify yourself. I will delete criticisms of my comment policy, vulgarities, cut-and-paste jobs from other sources and any suggestion of violence towards anyone. I will also delete sweeping generalizations about mainstream parties or ideologies, i.e. identity politics. My decisions on these matters are made on a case by case basis, and may be affected by my mood that day, my access to the blog at the time the comment was made or other information that isn’t readily apparent.